Confused on concept of finding voltage drop across a resistor

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around understanding voltage drops across resistors in electrical circuits, specifically applying Kirchhoff's laws. Participants express confusion regarding the selection of current paths and the addition of voltage sources in calculations.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Problem interpretation, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants question how to determine the correct path for current flow and which voltage sources to include in calculations. They explore the reasoning behind using specific loops in Kirchhoff's law and express uncertainty about the definitions and roles of currents at junctions.

Discussion Status

Some guidance has been offered regarding the application of Kirchhoff's laws and the reasoning behind current direction and voltage source selection. However, multiple interpretations and confusions remain regarding the choice of loops and the treatment of currents at nodes.

Contextual Notes

Participants are navigating the complexities of circuit analysis, including the definitions of currents at nodes and the implications of applying Kirchhoff's laws. There is an acknowledgment of the need for clarity on the assumptions made in the problem setup.

mr_coffee
Messages
1,613
Reaction score
1
Hello everyone I have a slight problem. I am confused on how you
know what path current is going to travel and also what voltage sources
your suppose to add up to a specific resistor. For example here is my picture, already solved:
The directions where to find the value of ix,
the orignal problem only had the values of each voltage source and the values of the ressitors
and it already had ix labeled.

http://img326.imageshack.us/img326/681/lastscan8rj.jpg

I'm confused on how they found I1, I1 and I3. I understand current travels
from high potential to low potential and also always comes out of the positive
side of a voltage source. So i understand the drawing of the current arrows.
But for example, when they found I1 = (20V+5V-10V)/5 OHMS = 3A.
Why did they add up those voltage sources? how did they know the
current was going to go that path and not just go around the top smaller loop?
so I1 = (5V)/5OHMS ? then they found I2 = (20V-10V)/10OHMS = 1A.
Also confused. how did they know I2's ressitor was going to have 20V
pass through it and 10V's but not the 5 V's?
Then finally I3 = (10V)/2 OHMS = 5A.
Why did they only use 10V? why wouldn't u use all of them?
See this is where I'm very confused. I get the concept of kcl,
Currents at a junction = Currents out a junction.
I also understand kvl, where the sum of higher potential = lower potential.
Thanks, any help would be great! :biggrin:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
But for example, when they found I1 = (20V+5V-10V)/5 OHMS = 3A.
Why did they add up those voltage sources? how did they know the
current was going to go that path and not just go around the top smaller loop?

This is an application of Kirchoff's law which simply states that the sum of the potentials around a loop is 0, i.e. energy is conserved. The loop being considered is the largest loop which contains 3 batteries (5, 10 an 20 Volts) and a single resistor (5 Ohms).
 
Thanks for the responce, but why did they choose the longest loop? that's my confusion, how do you know which path to choose to figure it out? Perhaps someone can explain it easier on this picture:

t3-7.gif


okay they say:
Below are the 5 Ohm's Law equations needed.
V3 = 2 x 3
V4 = 4I4
V7 = 7I7
V8 = 8I7
V9 = 9I6

If the top node and the bottom node are selected, these are the resulting KCL equations:
Top Node: -2 - I5 - I7 = 0
Bottom Node: 2 + I4 + __ = 0

Okay it all makes sense but why does V8 = 8*I7 and not 8*I5? how did they know I5 didn't take a right and go through V8? also V9 = 9I6, why couldn't I4 go through V9? And what are they talking about Top Node and bottom node?

KCL says, current in a junction = current out of junction. So why are they saying -2-I5-I7 = 0? all those currents are going INTO the junction so wouldn't those be positive? also when they say bottom node, 2+I4 + ? = 0, why are those positive? the question mark should be I6, which is correct, 2+I4+I6 = 0;
 
Last edited:
In this format, EACH branch (the part of a circuit from one node to another) gets its own label for current ... the Voltage across R8 is BY DEFINITION = I7*R8.

The statement -I7 = I5 + I2 means that I2 and I5 go into this node (solder spot) , and -I7 comes out.
I like to use "reasonable guess" for the directions of the current, but
it's okay to use the format you have started ... in words, it means that
the total current coming out of a node = 0 ... or the total into a node = 0.

ANY path you choose will give you a "correct equation" (if you do it right).
with practice, you tend to choose a path with the fewest unknowns.
Otherwise, just choose systematically different paths, and deal with the
multiple equations with multiple unknowns as simultaneous equations.
It works, but is harder math.
 

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
1K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
5K
  • · Replies 32 ·
2
Replies
32
Views
3K