Conservation of momentum for accelerating object

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers on the conservation of momentum in the context of collisions involving accelerating objects. Participants explore the implications of acceleration on momentum calculations and the conditions under which momentum is conserved during collisions.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • One participant questions whether the standard momentum formula (p = mv) applies when an object is accelerating, suggesting that Δv might be necessary in the context of collisions.
  • Another participant asserts that momentum is defined as mv and that if an object accelerates, its momentum increases, referencing Newton's second law in momentum format (F = Δp/Δt).
  • Some participants clarify that momentum is conserved only when there is no net external force acting on the system, noting that external forces can disrupt conservation during a collision.
  • A participant emphasizes that the conservation of momentum applies regardless of whether the collision is elastic or inelastic, and discusses the implications of mass change in systems like rockets.
  • There is a discussion about the relationship between acceleration and momentum, with one participant asserting that the contact force during a collision can be expressed as mass times the acceleration of the impacting object.
  • Another participant points out the distinction between acceleration and velocity, suggesting that relevant laws focus on momentum rather than acceleration.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on how to apply the conservation of momentum in the case of accelerating objects, with no consensus reached on whether the standard momentum formula is sufficient or if modifications are necessary. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the implications of acceleration on momentum calculations.

Contextual Notes

Some participants highlight the importance of external forces and the time duration of collisions in determining whether momentum can be considered conserved. The discussion also reflects varying interpretations of the relationship between acceleration and momentum.

terryds
Messages
392
Reaction score
13
I always see that a ball moving in a constant speed collide with another ball is common conservation of momentum problems. Obviously, I know that the momentum is mass*velocity

But, what if the ball accelerates and collides with another ball ?
I think I can't use mass*velocity for the momentum because the velocity is not constant.

Then, I think that I might have missed the Δ symbol.
Because I think that the conservation of momentum is derived like below.
F = -F
m Δv/Δt = m Δv/Δt
Because the object A contacts object B at the same time as the object B contacts object A, so we can cancel Δt
So, m Δv = m Δv

So, is the formula m Δv ?
But, I doubt it, because I think non-accelerating objects which has Δv = 0 since its velocity doesn't change also have momentum
Or, maybe the formula is mass times the velocity the object has when contacting another object.
But, I don't know how to derive the formula (p = m*v) since F = ma = m Δv/Δt has a delta symbol and momentum formula doesn't have delta symbol.

So, What is the momentum formula ?
Is it mass times the velocity the object has when contacting another object or m v ?
Or is it m Δv ?
If the formula is m v , Please tell me how to derive that formula.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The momentum is mv. If the velocity increases (the body is accelerating) the momentum increases too. This is what Newton's second law states (in the momentum format): if there is net force acting on the system, the momentum changes (F=Δp/Δt).
The momentum is conserved only if the net force is zero. If there is a non-zero net force, the momentum is not conserved, of course.

So for the collision described, if there is an external force acting on one or both colliding bodies, the momentum is not conserved. By external force I mean a force which is not due to the interaction between the colliding bodies but interaction with other bodies, not participating in the collision.
However, as the collision time is (usually) very short it may be possible to neglect the change in total momentum that occurred during the collision. It depends on the problem if you can or cannot do this.
 
terryds said:
has a delta symbol and momentum formula doesn't have delta symbol
Delta means difference. The difference of two momentum quantities is still a momentum. Just like the difference of two lengths is still a length.
 
If just the two balls are involved, the law of conservation of momentum reads mAvA = mBvB.

This law is valid whether the impact is elastic or non-elastic. Also observe that Newton's original formula reads [itex]\frac{d(mv)}{dt}= \frac{dm}{dt}\cdot v + m\cdot \frac{dv}{dt}[/itex]. Usually the mass is constant, so [itex]\frac{dm}{dt} = 0[/itex]. When your you are dealing with rockets, you need the complete formula (the mass decreases as the fuel is used up).
 
Svein said:
If just the two balls are involved, the law of conservation of momentum reads mAvA = mBvB.

This law is valid whether the impact is elastic or non-elastic. Also observe that Newton's original formula reads [itex]\frac{d(mv)}{dt}= \frac{dm}{dt}\cdot v + m\cdot \frac{dv}{dt}[/itex]. Usually the mass is constant, so [itex]\frac{dm}{dt} = 0[/itex]. When your you are dealing with rockets, you need the complete formula (the mass decreases as the fuel is used up).

A.T. said:
Delta means difference. The difference of two momentum quantities is still a momentum. Just like the difference of two lengths is still a length.

Suppose ball A is accelerating and going to hit ball B which is static. And, both balls have the same mass, and the collision is elastic
After the collision, the acceleration of the ball B is the same as the initial acceleration of the ball A, right ?
And, after the collision, ball A's acceleration is the same as B but, with opposite direction, right ?
The contact force is mass * the acceleration the ball A has before collision, right ?

nasu said:
The momentum is mv. If the velocity increases (the body is accelerating) the momentum increases too. This is what Newton's second law states (in the momentum format): if there is net force acting on the system, the momentum changes (F=Δp/Δt).
The momentum is conserved only if the net force is zero. If there is a non-zero net force, the momentum is not conserved, of course.

So for the collision described, if there is an external force acting on one or both colliding bodies, the momentum is not conserved. By external force I mean a force which is not due to the interaction between the colliding bodies but interaction with other bodies, not participating in the collision.
However, as the collision time is (usually) very short it may be possible to neglect the change in total momentum that occurred during the collision. It depends on the problem if you can or cannot do this.

I think there is no external force when the ball is moving. The external force is just to get the ball moving (accelerate).
 
terryds said:
Suppose ball A is accelerating and going to hit ball B which is static. And, both balls have the same mass, and the collision is elastic
After the collision, the acceleration of the ball B is the same as the initial acceleration of the ball A, right ?
And, after the collision, ball A's acceleration is the same as B but, with opposite direction, right ?
The contact force is mass * the acceleration the ball A has before collision, right ?
None of the relevant laws say anything about acceleration. Use the "conservation of momentum" formula. In addition, for an elastic collision, the kinetic energy is conserved.
 
terryds said:
Suppose ball A is accelerating and going to hit ball B which is static. And, both balls have the same mass, and the collision is elastic
After the collision, the acceleration of the ball B is the same as the initial acceleration of the ball A, right ?
And, after the collision, ball A's acceleration is the same as B but, with opposite direction, right ?
The contact force is mass * the acceleration the ball A has before collision, right ?
You seem to confuse acceleration and velocity.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 30 ·
2
Replies
30
Views
3K
  • · Replies 53 ·
2
Replies
53
Views
5K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 60 ·
3
Replies
60
Views
7K