fobos3
- 33
- 1
Is there a way to deliver constant power to a varying load. Any ideas will be appreciated.
The discussion revolves around the challenge of delivering constant power to a varying load, specifically focusing on the technical approaches and circuit designs that could achieve this goal. Participants explore various methods, including the use of amplifiers and analog multipliers, while addressing the complexities involved in maintaining a constant power output regardless of load resistance.
Participants present multiple competing views on circuit design and component selection, with no clear consensus on the best approach to achieve constant power delivery to a varying load.
Participants note limitations regarding the accuracy of components and the need for precise calculations, particularly concerning the gain of operational amplifiers and the characteristics of logarithmic elements.
russ_watters said:Could you elaborate please - the question doesn't seem to make much sense.
fobos3 said:I've attached my idea.
U2 is a differential amplifier with gain 1. U1 is there to make sure the voltage at + and - is the same.
rbj said:the idea is good. i think R1 should be lower resistance and U2 gain be larger.
what do you plan to use for your analog multiplyer? you might want to look into something from Analog Devices, say the AD633 or AD734 or something like that. you can get some of them pretty cheap ($8) at Digi-Key.
you also want to have some pot in there to set and control the power.
fobos3 said:I was thinking with two log amplifiers then a summing amplifier and exponential amplifier.
[tex]e^{\ln a+\ln b}=ab[/tex]
With something like LM324(quad) which costs 10p(£0.10).
rbj said:you still need a logarithmic element (actually 3 of them). run-of-the-mill diodes don't follow the curve good enough. what do you plan to use for that?
fobos3 said:Transistors.
Here's my final schematics. I haven't calculated the values of the resistors so all are 10k.
Edit
Still need to figure out the gain for each op amp taking into account the offset voltage. In particular the log amplifiers.