marlowgs
- 24
- 1
If I create an electromagnetic wave with electric and magnetic fields partially out of phase, would it behave the same as a mass with velocity less than the speed of light?
The discussion revolves around the behavior of electromagnetic waves, particularly in relation to mass and velocity, and how these concepts intersect with pair production in quantum physics. Participants explore the implications of creating electromagnetic waves with electric and magnetic fields that are partially out of phase, and whether such waves can be treated similarly to mass moving at subluminal speeds.
Participants express differing views on the applicability of classical versus quantum models in explaining pair production, indicating that there is no consensus on how to approach the topic. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the treatment of electromagnetic waves in relation to mass and pair production.
Participants note the limitations of classical models in explaining quantum phenomena, and there are unresolved questions about the conditions under which electromagnetic waves can be treated as classical entities.
marlowgs said:In pair-production, a light wave (in-phase E&M) comes close to a heavy particle and turns into two masses with momentum, but the light wave needs to have a minimum energy to produce the particles. I’m wondering what happens if less than the minimum is there. Do the electric and magnetic fields go out of phase for a short time as the photon swipes past the heavy particle and does the partially out-of-phase photon act as an intermediate particle.
Interesting question! A quick search about "pair production in classical electrodynamics" yields a paper by A. Carati as well as more recently, a Powerpoint and a youtube presentation by Martin Land. Obviously it's "work-in-progress".PeterDonis said:[..]
I don't know if anyone has even tried to model pair production with the light being treated classically. I suspect it wouldn't work.