Criminal offences in maths textbooks

  • Thread starter matt grime
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Textbooks
In summary, the conversation highlights several frustrations with math textbooks, including incorrect facts, misuse of symbols, and unclear explanations. The conversation also touches on the issue of providing answers for exercises, which can hinder the learning process for students. The speakers also express their frustration with authors and editors who fail to acknowledge or correct serious errors in their books. They emphasize the importance of understanding and checking one's own work, rather than relying on provided answers.
  • #36
matt grime said:
The Boubaki syndrome really means the writing of mathematics in its 'purest' form, i.e. statements with minimal hypotheses and a very dry style without motivation and in principle from the ground up. The lay reader at this point should not think that by motivation I mean solving a problem in the real world. I mean explaining the reasons why one might wish to prove such a theorem.

The style has its benefits, and its drawbacks, naturally. The reader can decide for themselves if they want articles with lots of statements like 'let M be a monoid, now...'

I did a google on "Boubaki syndrome", and it yielded one single hit - which was this very page. Though I think I'm pretty sure from the discussion provided here what is meant by the term, I'm curious as to whether it is the actual name of the phenomenon?

I do not doubt, though, that there are several authors to whom one could argue that the phenomenon was attributable to the extent that eponymocity is justified.
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
  • #37
It helps to spell Bourbaki right. :smile:
 
  • #38
Nesk said:
I did a google on "Boubaki syndrome", and it yielded one single hit


woo-hoo, we're a googlewhack. That means I've now been a googlewhackee twice.
 
  • #39
jhat21 said:
Criminal offenses in math textbooks:

#2 Useless diagrams.
Refer to fig 1.a on page#<somepagefaraway>,
fig 1.a (a right triangle with the right angle <ABC labeled 90 degrees)
what is the sin of angle <ABC?
Just say what is sin(90) !

When they make you do problems according to the diagram *they* assign, using the variables *they* pick, so you have to flip back and forth to their stupid pictures and premises. Just so you have to use *their* book! I know what sin90 is but what the hell is sin (<ABC) is unless I buy their textbook?!

I have something similar to this. My calculus booked had a theorem and stated (proof in section 14.3) We were in Chapter 7. I look ahead to find the proof and turned out...the proof wasn't there.
 
<h2>1. What are criminal offences in maths textbooks?</h2><p>Criminal offences in maths textbooks refer to the illegal or unethical actions that a person may take while using or creating a maths textbook. These can include plagiarism, copyright infringement, and fraud.</p><h2>2. How do criminal offences in maths textbooks affect students?</h2><p>Criminal offences in maths textbooks can negatively impact students by providing them with inaccurate or misleading information. This can lead to confusion and hinder their learning. Additionally, if a textbook is found to have committed a criminal offence, it may be removed from circulation, causing inconvenience to students.</p><h2>3. What are some examples of criminal offences in maths textbooks?</h2><p>Examples of criminal offences in maths textbooks include copying and pasting content from other sources without proper citation, using copyrighted material without permission, and intentionally providing incorrect information to manipulate data or results.</p><h2>4. How can we prevent criminal offences in maths textbooks?</h2><p>To prevent criminal offences in maths textbooks, it is important for authors to thoroughly research and fact-check their content before publishing. They should also properly cite any sources used and obtain permission for copyrighted material. Additionally, publishers can implement strict guidelines and procedures for reviewing and editing textbooks to ensure they are free of criminal offences.</p><h2>5. What are the consequences of committing a criminal offence in a maths textbook?</h2><p>The consequences of committing a criminal offence in a maths textbook can vary, but may include legal action, fines, and damage to one's reputation. In the academic setting, the consequences can include disciplinary action, loss of credibility, and potential removal of the textbook from circulation.</p>

1. What are criminal offences in maths textbooks?

Criminal offences in maths textbooks refer to the illegal or unethical actions that a person may take while using or creating a maths textbook. These can include plagiarism, copyright infringement, and fraud.

2. How do criminal offences in maths textbooks affect students?

Criminal offences in maths textbooks can negatively impact students by providing them with inaccurate or misleading information. This can lead to confusion and hinder their learning. Additionally, if a textbook is found to have committed a criminal offence, it may be removed from circulation, causing inconvenience to students.

3. What are some examples of criminal offences in maths textbooks?

Examples of criminal offences in maths textbooks include copying and pasting content from other sources without proper citation, using copyrighted material without permission, and intentionally providing incorrect information to manipulate data or results.

4. How can we prevent criminal offences in maths textbooks?

To prevent criminal offences in maths textbooks, it is important for authors to thoroughly research and fact-check their content before publishing. They should also properly cite any sources used and obtain permission for copyrighted material. Additionally, publishers can implement strict guidelines and procedures for reviewing and editing textbooks to ensure they are free of criminal offences.

5. What are the consequences of committing a criminal offence in a maths textbook?

The consequences of committing a criminal offence in a maths textbook can vary, but may include legal action, fines, and damage to one's reputation. In the academic setting, the consequences can include disciplinary action, loss of credibility, and potential removal of the textbook from circulation.

Similar threads

  • General Math
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • General Math
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • General Math
Replies
13
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
281
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
55
Views
3K
  • General Math
Replies
16
Views
3K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
24
Views
2K
Back
Top