Automotive Death of a car battery and related issues

Click For Summary
A four-year-old Toyota Etios Liva's battery was declared "dead" after minimal usage, raising concerns about the accuracy of the service personnel's assessment. The owner suspects the battery may have simply lost charge due to inactivity and questions the necessity of weekly engine starts to maintain battery health. Recommendations include using a trickle charger, though access to power is limited due to rental agreements. The discussion highlights the importance of proper battery maintenance, including regular charging and load testing, to extend battery life. Overall, the owner plans to manage the battery more effectively moving forward, including potentially removing it for charging at home.
  • #31
Indeed. My car turns off the engine automatically at stops. So on the school run it restarts about a dozen times in 30 mins.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #32
CWatters said:
Indeed. My car turns off the engine automatically at stops. So on the school run it restarts about a dozen times in 30 mins.
New generation stop-start features are engineered somewhat differently to older lead-acid systems. For example, they may contain a supercapacitor (very low impedance = very fast charging) to support a sealed gel-electrolye battery.

Although 30min minimum charge for one start is very conservative even for lead-acid, I would not try starting an unsupported lead-acid battery once every 30sec with only idling between. It WILL die faster.
 
  • Like
Likes Wrichik Basu and OmCheeto
  • #33
mic* said:
New generation stop-start features are engineered somewhat differently to older lead-acid systems. For example, they may contain a supercapacitor (very low impedance = very fast charging) to support a sealed gel-electrolye battery.

Although 30min minimum charge for one start is very conservative even for lead-acid, I would not try starting an unsupported lead-acid battery once every 30sec with only idling between. It WILL die faster.
Not to mention your starter. I did the experiment on my last vehicle, and my starter failed within a week.
 
  • Like
Likes Wrichik Basu and mic*
  • #34
CWatters said:
Indeed. My car turns off the engine automatically at stops. So on the school run it restarts about a dozen times in 30 mins.
Even if I keep the issue of the battery aside based on what @mic* said, doesn't that consume more fuel? I generally had the idea that an engine in good condition, if kept in idling state at traffic signals, consumes less fuel than what it would have consumed when switched off and turned on again and again (I assume that air conditioners, heaters and defoggers are all switched off).
 
  • #35
Wrichik Basu said:
Even if I keep the issue of the battery aside based on what @mic* said, doesn't that consume more fuel? I generally had the idea that an engine in good condition, if kept in idling state at traffic signals, consumes less fuel than what it would have consumed when switched off and turned on again and again (I assume that air conditioners, heaters and defoggers are all switched off).
In short, no.

Maybe in the past it could not have worked so well, but electronic fuelling and engine sensing is relatively precise these days. The engine will be warm, so there will be no "cold start" enrichment. And the engine knows exactly where it is so you generally find they fire immediately, rather than needing that extra turn of the crank before running. They fire up so quick that by the time your foot has moved from the brake to the accelerator, your engine is already running again.
 
  • Like
Likes CWatters and Wrichik Basu
  • #36
My understanding is that auto start stop does or can discharge the battery deeper than otherwise but they have a BMS system that turns off the auto start stop mode if it gets discharged too much. They may also use a slightly larger battery than on comparable cars without auto start stop. Don't think the battery is supported with a super cap, at least not on my car.
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters, Wrichik Basu and mic*
  • #37
CWatters said:
My understanding is that auto start stop does or can discharge the battery deeper than otherwise but they have a BMS system that turns off the auto start stop mode if it gets discharged too much. They may also use a slightly larger battery than on comparable cars without auto start stop. Don't think the battery is supported with a super cap, at least not on my car.
Larger bttery units seem to be another approach. SC's are rated at >500,000 cycles so they are not considered a servicable part. They will outlast your steering wheel.
 
  • #38
@CWatters, I just had a bit of a dig around and I must admit it is hard to find proprietary info on SC use in fuelled vehicles, especially without being used in connection to some form of kinetic energy recovery system. Ie, an SC integrated ONLY for stop-start battery support.
 
  • #39
Wrichik Basu said:
We have a Toyota Etios Liva, four years old, petrol variant. ... Our car is not used much. Usually on an average, it is driven for around 14km per month.

Is this number (14km per month) correct? The four-year old car has 670 km (~400 miles)? At the advertised mileage (about 20 km per liter) you have burned around 34 liters (9 gallons, US) in the past four years?

I have had vehicles with low use like this (not cars, but motorcycles and scooters) and I would expect all kinds of problems: gasoline turned to sludge, clogged carburetor, dead battery, flat spots on the tires, mice eating the wiring, etc. If the use is really this low I would advise either drive it more, or sell it and use taxis to get around.
 
  • Like
Likes mic*
  • #40
gmax137 said:
Is this number (14km per month) correct? The four-year old car has 670 km (~400 miles)? At the advertised mileage (about 20 km per liter) you have burned around 34 liters (9 gallons, US) in the past four years
Well, I didn't think of such detailed calculations. The average value was of 2018. In the previous years, it has traveled quite a distance. The odometer reading currently is a little greater than 5000km.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
5K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
66
Views
6K
  • · Replies 41 ·
2
Replies
41
Views
10K
Replies
54
Views
11K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
13K