Determine the transfer function of the block diagram

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
icesalmon
Messages
270
Reaction score
13
Homework Statement
Determine the transfer function of the block diagram
Relevant Equations
Equations for Block Diagram Algebra
Step 1: I first started by reducing the inside of the block diagram of picture "bd" (the portion with G1 and the negative feedback G2)
I obtained G1/[1 + G1G2]
I'll call this term "F"

Step 2: Then I'm left with two terms feeding into a summing point:
F - G3
I'll call this term "K"

I can reduce this diagram as I did in the first step:

T(s) = K / [1 - K*G4 ]

The solution, on the other hand, is adding G3 to F as indicated in the second picture I've attached
"bd2"
I am not sure if this is a mistake (to add G3 instead of subtracting it) or if I'm not seeing something.
Any help is appreciated, apologies if I've left anything out or made my solution unclear in anyway.
 
Attachments
  • Block diagram with input entering a summing junction marked plus, then a second summing junction marked minus feeding G1, with a feedback path G2 returning to it, a summing junction marked minus after G1, G3 feeding the output summing junction, and G4 in a feedback path from the output back to the first summing junction.
    bd.PNG
    8.7 KB · Views: 277
  • Step 2 block diagram: a summing junction with a plus sign feeds G1 over (1 + G1G2) plus G3, with a G4 feedback path returning to the summing junction.
    bd2.PNG
    34.3 KB · Views: 259
Has your class covered Mason's gain formula?
 
Giving it another look... I personally agree with you with subtracting ##G_3##.
 
Joshy said:
Giving it another look... I personally agree with you with subtracting ##G_3##.
any luck? I think the solution is making a mistake.