Determining Arcsin(Sin[7Pi/5])

  • Thread starter Thread starter Beer w/Straw
  • Start date Start date
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
8 replies · 14K views
Beer w/Straw
Messages
49
Reaction score
0
The problem is... What to put as my answer :P arcsin(Sin(7Pi/5))



http://mathworld.wolfram.com/TrigonometryAnglesPi5.html



The solution is -2Pi/5

The problem I'm having is this appears to me as a trick question. Would it be acceptable to say

sin(7pi/5) = -(sqrt(5/8+sqrt(5)/8)) make a note of an identity. Then simply say arcsin(-(sqrt(5/8+sqrt(5)/8))) =-2Pi/5?

Assuming this is correct, would not all the work I just cut out be acceptable because I'm not trying to prove the identity over again?

Comments suggestions would be appreciated.

Thanks.


PS: Sorry for lack of tex.
 
Physics news on Phys.org


I think you need to look at where the arcsin is defined.
 


This is much easier than you are making it. There is no reason to even think about the actual value of sin(7pi/5). As Hogger suggested, think about the definition of "arcsin". The only "tricky" point is getting the correct range for the answer. 7pi/5 itself is larger than pi. What's wrong with that?
 


I don't understand, am I missing an identity somewhere?

ArcSin[7Pi/5] is imaginary

Sin[7Pi/5] is not

And ArcSin[Sin[7Pi/5]] is not imaginary.
 


You are not asked to find arcsin(7pi/5).

If x is in the domain of the Sin function (which has a restricted domain, unlike the sin function), then ArcSin(Sin(x)) = x. 7pi/5 is not in the domain of the Sin function, so what you need to do is find a value of x in this restricted domain for which Sin(x) = sin(7pi/5).
 


No, I was responding to something Beer w/Straw wrote in post 4:
I don't understand, am I missing an identity somewhere?
ArcSin[7Pi/5] is imaginary
 


Well the definition ArcSin[Sinx]=x where -Pi/2=<x=<Pi/2 ...

But it equals -x ...

sin(7π/5), being sin (π + α) = - sinα and - sinα = sin(-α)

So, just slap a minus sign infront of 2Pi/5?
 


You're looking at the wrong identity. The sine function is symmetric about the line x = π/2. This means that sin(π/2 + a) = sin(π/2 - a). Find a value of x in [-π/2, π/2] such that sin(x) = sin(7π/5).