Determining error in a linear gradient/slope

  • Thread starter Thread starter Harry Smith
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Error Linear
AI Thread Summary
To determine the error in the gradient of a linear graph, the user has calculated the maximum and minimum gradients from the worst lines of fit, yielding mmin = 9.79 m² and mmax = 12.06 m². The average gradient is reported as mavg = (11.20 ± 1.14) m², but the user is uncertain how to interpret these values in terms of error. Clarification is sought on the meaning of "error," with discussions around standard deviation and measurement accuracy. The accuracy of the measuring device is noted to be ±0.25 m, and calculations involving this error are mentioned, though they require further clarification. Understanding these calculations and their implications for error analysis in lab reports is essential for accurate data interpretation.
Harry Smith
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Hi, so I'm currently writing a lab report and need to determine the error in the value of my graphs gradient, m. I have found the maximum and minimum gradient from the 'worst' lines of fit but am lost where to go from there. My data analysis/statistics lecture notes are no help on this topic, neither is Google. It seems like it should be an easy topic!

m = 11.20 m2
mmin = 9.79 m2
mmax = 12.06 m2

and I've found the mean gradient and its deviation (though this is little use)

mavg = (11.20 ± 1.14) m2

The data in y is
11.39 ± 1.67
21.39 ± 2.29
33.06 ± 2.85
47.27 ± 3.40
56.25 ± 3.71
66.02 ± 4.02

(all in m2)

Thanks in advance!
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Harry Smith said:
Hi, so I'm currently writing a lab report and need to determine the error in the value of my graphs gradient, m.


What you mean by "error"? One sees quantities in reports given in notation like "9.35 +/- 2.61", but unfortunately, I know of no standard interpretation for this notation. Such notation often means that the measurements have a mean value of 9.35 and a standard deviation of 2.61. However, sometimes the notation means that the measured quantity is known (with certainty) to be between the stated limits.

I have found the maximum and minimum gradient from the 'worst' lines of fit but am lost where to go from there.

I'm lost as to how you would define a "worst" line of fit. However, your remark at least reveals that you are fitting linear graphs to the data.
The data in y is
11.39 ± 1.67
21.39 ± 2.29
33.06 ± 2.85
47.27 ± 3.40
56.25 ± 3.71
66.02 ± 4.02

(all in m2)

Why didn't you state the x values?

Does your data consist of many individual measurements of (x,y)? For example, assuming the y value 21.39 is for x = 1, do you have many different measurements like (1,22.28), (1,18.33)... ? Or do you have just one measurement (1,21.39) and are getting the +/- 2.29 from some manufacturers specification for the measuring device?
 
By error I mean standard deviation. Apologies.

By worst line of fit I mean the maximum mmax or minimum mmin possible gradient achievable from the set of data within the bounds of the error.

The x values are 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 with no error so it needn't be considered.

The ± 2.29 originates from the datum it corresponds with. The accuracy of the measuring device was to the nearest 0.25 m. The datum were then averaged, with error Δr of
\Delta r = \sqrt{2 \cdot (0.25)^2}​
This was then squared, with error Δr2 of
\Delta r ^2 = r ^2 \cdot \sqrt{2 (\frac{\Delta r}{r}) ^2}​
where r2 = y.

Hope that cleared it up.
 
Harry Smith said:
The accuracy of the measuring device was to the nearest 0.25 m. The datum were then averaged, with error Δr of
\Delta r = \sqrt{2 \cdot (0.25)^2}​
This was then squared, with error Δr2 of
\Delta r ^2 = r ^2 \cdot \sqrt{2 (\frac{\Delta r}{r}) ^2}​
where r2 = y.

I don't understand those calculations. Is the accuracy of measuring device given as a "percentage error" instead of an error in meters?
 
Stephen Tashi said:
I don't understand those calculations. Is the accuracy of measuring device given as a "percentage error" instead of an error in meters?
It can be given as either. Percentage error just represents the percentage of the deviation from the value.
 
Back
Top