Determining Minimum Height to Complete a Loop

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
1 reply · 30K views
crushedcorn
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
This question was posted on Khan Academy. I attempted it after watching all of their great Work and Energy videos, but the way they arrived at the answer was way above my skill level even after reviewing the videos a number of times. Here is the question:

What is the minimum height h of a slope that must be constructed in order for a rider in the cart with a combined mass m = 80.0 kg to complete the loop with a radius r = 10.0 meters safely, assuming a frictionless trip?

4e906cd94e8d150a1b45f273793579c77b38f5e6.png

How would you answer this question? The way that they arrived at their answer is below. Is there any alternative/more concise way to arrive at the same answer? I would have never guessed to proceed in the way noted in Hint #3.

We can use the Conservation of Energy formula to evaluate these two points: at the top of the hill and at the top of the loop.

caffd013cb948bf84803ad975be9a21722638d0a.png

Hint #2
At the top of the hill, the kinetic energy is zero, and the potential energy is mgh.

863284b2d565dbf72b029fb3e30cc3989ddc2627.png

Hint #3
At the top of the loop, we must derive another formula to connect ideas together by using Newton’s Second Law to describe the forces acting on the cart and then to solve for v:

d26b49c5ae2f46c757736dc22d56742fe0011f3c.png

Hint #4
This expression is for the velocity at the top of the loop since there is no normal force only at that point. Additionally, h = 2r such that the potential energy is mg(2r).

40419bee3dd2001dd8df7d462b1a36a7f664028c.png

Hint #5
The correct answer is 2.5. Since the radius of the loop is 10 meters, then 2.5r is 25 meters.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
crushedcorn said:
This question was posted on Khan Academy. I attempted it after watching all of their great Work and Energy videos, but the way they arrived at the answer was way above my skill level even after reviewing the videos a number of times.

I believe this is the easiest and smallest way to answer this question - I would certainly have solved the question this way .

Does this answer your doubt ?

crushedcorn said:
I would have never guessed to proceed in the way noted in Hint #3.

Do you know your circular motion ?