Difference between spin repulsion and electrostatic repulsion of an electron?

In summary, "spin repulsion" and "electrostatic repulsion" refer to two unrelated phenomena. The former is related to the orbital approximation, which takes into account the combined effects of nuclear shielding and electron-electron repulsion. The latter is a result of the Pauli exclusion principle, which restricts the arrangement of electrons in an atom due to their indistinguishability. This principle is not related to electrical charge, as many may assume, but rather stems from a deeper property of nature.
  • #1
Philipsmett
78
4
What is the difference between spin repulsion and electrostatic repulsion of an electron? Is this the same mechanism?
 
  • Like
Likes Spinnor
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
What you term "spin repulsion" and "electrostatic repulsion" are unrelated things. To my mind, Dan Dill gives a good explanation regarding both "effects" in
Many-electron atoms: Fermi holes and Fermi heaps Notes on ... :

"First, once there is more than a single electron, the combined effect of the electrical shielding of the nuclear charge and interelectron electrical repulsion jumbles things up. It turns out that these effects of nuclear shielding and electron-electron repulsion can be taken into account to a good approximation as relatively simple corrections to what we would expect if each electron were in the atom all by itself. This is known as the orbital approximation.

Second, and far more important, is that an amazing new property of the physical world comes into play, tracing to the fact that all electrons are, as far as we know, indistinguishable from one another. Once this indistinguishability is taken into account, through what is known as the Pauli exclusion principle, the result is a profound restriction on the way electrons can arrange themselves in an atom. It is this restriction that accounts for the periodic properties of the elements and so, ultimately, the structure of the physical world as we know it.

You may have learned the "rule" that no more than two electrons can be in the same orbital. If you have, you may also have puzzled about why such a rule is so. If you have decided, like many people who have been presented with just the rule without any explanation, that it has to do with electrical repulsion—that it reflects the electrons repelling one another due to their electrical charge—then you are in for a neat surprise. The "rule" instead traces to a deep algebraic property of nature that has nothing whatsoever to do with the charge on electrons!......"
 
  • Like
Likes bhobba

1. What is spin repulsion and electrostatic repulsion of an electron?

Spin repulsion and electrostatic repulsion are two types of repulsive forces that act on electrons in an atom. Spin repulsion is caused by the parallel alignment of electron spins, while electrostatic repulsion is caused by the negative charges of electrons repelling each other.

2. How do spin repulsion and electrostatic repulsion affect the stability of an atom?

Both spin repulsion and electrostatic repulsion play important roles in determining the stability of an atom. Too much spin repulsion can lead to an unstable electron configuration, while too much electrostatic repulsion can cause the atom to break apart.

3. What is the difference between spin repulsion and electrostatic repulsion?

The main difference between spin repulsion and electrostatic repulsion is the cause of the repulsive force. Spin repulsion is caused by the parallel alignment of electron spins, while electrostatic repulsion is caused by the negative charges of electrons repelling each other.

4. How do spin repulsion and electrostatic repulsion affect the energy levels of electrons?

Spin repulsion and electrostatic repulsion can both affect the energy levels of electrons in an atom. Spin repulsion can cause electrons to occupy higher energy levels, while electrostatic repulsion can cause electrons to be pushed into higher energy levels or even leave the atom completely.

5. Can spin repulsion and electrostatic repulsion be overcome?

Yes, both spin repulsion and electrostatic repulsion can be overcome by other forces. For example, the attractive force of the nucleus can counteract the repulsive forces and hold the electrons in place. Additionally, the repulsive forces can be balanced out by other electrons in the atom.

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
779
Replies
2
Views
891
  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
44
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
818
Replies
15
Views
955
Replies
3
Views
991
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
831
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
6
Views
1K
Back
Top