Differential for Real Valued Functions of Several Variables

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
Math Amateur
Gold Member
MHB
Messages
3,920
Reaction score
48
I am reading the book "Several Real Variables" by Shmuel Kantorovitz ... ...

I am currently focused on Chapter 2: Derivation ... ...

I need help with an aspect of Kantorovitz's Example 3 on pages 65-66 ...

Kantorovitz's Example 3 on pages 65-66 reads as follows:
Printed textbook page showing Example 3: f: R^3 to R with f(0)=0, f(x) = x1 sin(x2x3)/||x||^a for x nonzero, a a real constant less than 2, followed by text on verifying differentiability at 0 with zero differential.

Typeset proof text showing that |phi_0(h)|/||h|| = |h1 sin(h2 h3)|/||h||^(a+1) is bounded by ||h||^(2-a), which tends to 0 as h approaches 0 since a < 2, so df at 0 is zero.

In the above example, we read the following:"... ... ##\frac{ \mid \phi_0 (h) \mid }{ \| h \| } = \frac{ \mid h_1 \text{ sin } (h_2 h_3) \mid }{ \| h \|^{ a + 1 } }## ... ... ... "
My question is as follows:In the Section on The Differential (see scanned text below) ...

Kantorovitz defines ##\phi_x(h)## as follows:

##\phi_x(h) := f(x +h) - f(x) - Lh##

so that

##\phi_0(h) := f(0 +h) - f(0 ) - Lh = f(h) - f(0)## ...... BUT in the Example ... as I understand it ... ##f(0)## does not exist for the function in Example 3 ...? ...

... BUT ... Kantorovitz effectively gives ##\mid \phi_0 (h) \mid = \frac{ \mid h_1 \text{ sin } (h_2 h_3) \mid }{ \| h \| }##
Can someone please explain how Kantorovitz gets this value for ##\mid \phi_0 (h) \mid## when ##f(0)## does not exist?Help will be much appreciated ...

Peter==============================================================================

***NOTE***

Readers of the above post may be helped by having access to Kantorovitz' Section on "The Differential" ... so I am providing the same ... as follows:
Scanned textbook page titled The Differential, with definitions of linear functionals, the representation Lh = h · a, and a proof using the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality.

Scanned textbook page on the differential of a real-valued function of several variables, with displayed equations defining the remainder phi_x(h) and the limit condition as h tends to 0.

Printed textbook page: item 2 states that if f is differentiable at x in R^k, the linear functional L satisfying (2.5) is unique and called the differential of f at x, denoted df(x) or df|_x; Eq. (2.6): f(x+h) - f(x) = df|_x h + o(||h||) for ||h|| < r.


Hope that helps in understanding the post ...

Peter
 
Attachments
  • Printed textbook page showing Example 3: f: R^3 to R with f(0)=0, f(x) = x1 sin(x2x3)/||x||^a for x nonzero, a a real constant less than 2, followed by text on verifying differentiability at 0 with zero differential.
    Kantorovitz - 1 - Example 3 ... Page 65 ... PART 1 ... .png
    15.3 KB · Views: 909
  • Typeset proof text showing that |phi_0(h)|/||h|| = |h1 sin(h2 h3)|/||h||^(a+1) is bounded by ||h||^(2-a), which tends to 0 as h approaches 0 since a < 2, so df at 0 is zero.
    Kantorovitz - 2 - Example 3 ... Page 65 ... PART 2 ... .png
    17.1 KB · Views: 493
  • Scanned textbook page titled The Differential, with definitions of linear functionals, the representation Lh = h · a, and a proof using the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality.
    Kantorovitz - 1 - Sectiion on the DIfferential ... PART 1 ... .png
    27.4 KB · Views: 505
  • Scanned textbook page on the differential of a real-valued function of several variables, with displayed equations defining the remainder phi_x(h) and the limit condition as h tends to 0.
    Kantorovitz - 2 - Sectiion on the DIfferential ... PART 2 ... .png
    34.9 KB · Views: 499
  • Printed textbook page: item 2 states that if f is differentiable at x in R^k, the linear functional L satisfying (2.5) is unique and called the differential of f at x, denoted df(x) or df|_x; Eq. (2.6): f(x+h) - f(x) = df|_x h + o(||h||) for ||h|| < r.
    Kantorovitz - 3 - Sectiion on the DIfferential ... PART 3 ... .png
    13.2 KB · Views: 410
I've just noticed that the author defines the function to be zero at zero!

:frown: ... careless of me to miss that!

My apologies ...

Peter