Diffraction Grating Vs Double-Slit: Small angle Approx.

1 reply · 9K views · last reply
Beth N
Messages
41
Reaction score
4

Homework Statement



In double slit interference , the angle between the center bright fringe and the path length (aka the angle used to find the path length difference) can be approximate as a small angle. However, we cannot assume the angles of bright fringes due to diffraction gratings are small. Why? What is the difference? What angles are they exactly?
Slide titled 17.2 Analyzing double-slit interference showing the equations d sin θm = mλ for bright and d sin θm = (m + 1/2)λ for dark, with m = 0, 1, 2, and the relation y = L tan θ, alongside a diagram of two paths to a distant screen and a striped interference pattern labeled with the central maximum and ym positions.
Slide 17.3 The diffraction grating showing a grating with five slits, rays fanning to a screen with bright fringes labelled m = 0, 1, 2 and angles theta 1 and theta 2, plus a side diagram of plane waves through slits spaced d.

Homework Equations



##L= tan {\theta_m}##
##dsin {\theta_m}=m\lamda##

The Attempt at a Solution


I think in double slit interference, the angle can be approximated as small because we assume the distance between the 2 slits are very small compared to the distance between the slits and the screen opposite from them. Can't see why diffraction grating is different?
 
Attachments
  • Slide titled 17.2 Analyzing double-slit interference showing the equations d sin θm = mλ for bright and d sin θm = (m + 1/2)λ for dark, with m = 0, 1, 2, and the relation y = L tan θ, alongside a diagram of two paths to a distant screen and a striped interference pattern labeled with the central maximum and ym positions.
    Screen Shot 2018-10-27 at 9.04.54 PM.png
    35 KB · Views: 5,846
  • Slide 17.3 The diffraction grating showing a grating with five slits, rays fanning to a screen with bright fringes labelled m = 0, 1, 2 and angles theta 1 and theta 2, plus a side diagram of plane waves through slits spaced d.
    Screen Shot 2018-10-27 at 9.05.12 PM.png
    39 KB · Views: 5,731
A hint is that it depends on the size ## d ## which is often many times the wavelength for the case of just two slits, but typically is on the order of a wavelength for the spacing of the slits or lines in a diffraction grating. That isn't always the case, but it seems to be the assumption that you need to make here. (Edit: See the 3rd paragraph below for additional comments on this). ## \\ ## An item of interest here is the intensity peaks from a multi-slit or multi-line grating are narrower in the resulting ## \Delta \theta ## than the intensity peaks from a two-slit pattern, where for a grating with many slits or lines the intensity peak can be very narrow in the angular spread ## \Delta \theta ##. You can see this in the figures above where for even 5 slits, the intensity peaks are narrower than for the two-slit case in the appearance on the screen. For the two slit case, each of the peaks is a wide blob. For the 5 slit case, the bright red region of each intensity peak is a narrower stripe. This is not why the small angle approximation can not be used for a grating though. ## \\ ## The question doesn't seem to be what I would call a very accurate question. In addition, the more important feature of the difference between the double-slit and multi-slit or multi-line grating result is the more narrow intensity peaks that result. The "small angle" approximation does still apply for both the double slit and multi-slit or multi-line grating at small angles, and starts to break down as ## \theta ## gets larger for both cases. For this reason, I think the question really misses the boat.
 
Last edited: