Does charge conjugation affect parity?

2 replies · 3K views · last reply
silmaril89
Messages
85
Reaction score
0
"Notice that these transformations do not alter the chirality of particles. A left-handed neutrino would be taken by charge conjugation into a left-handed antineutrino, which does not interact in the Standard Model." --https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C-symmetry

The excerpt above seems to unambiguously answer this question. But, then:

"You can easily convince yourself (exercise II.1.9) that the charge conjugate of a left handed field is right handed and vice versa." --Quantum Field Theory in a Nutshell, A. Zee

These statements appear to be contradictory. What's going on here?

Also, it does seem easy to convince myself of Zee's comment (following Zee's convention that [itex]\psi \to \psi_c = \gamma^2 \psi^\ast[/itex]):

Suppose [itex]\psi[/itex] is left-handed (i.e. [itex]P_L \psi = \psi[/itex] and [itex]P_R \psi = 0[/itex]), then
[tex]P_L \psi_c = P_L \gamma^2 \psi^\ast = \gamma^2 P_R \psi^\ast = \gamma^2 (P_R \psi)^\ast = 0[/tex]
and
[tex]P_R \psi_c = P_R \gamma^2 \psi^\ast = \gamma^2 P_L \psi^\ast = \gamma^2 (P_L \psi)^\ast = \psi_c[/tex]
Therefore, it appears that Zee's comment is correct. Can anyone help me understand why the two quotes above are or are not in contradiction?
 
Both statements are technically true, but I think Zee's is misleading. If we work in basis where ##\gamma_5## is diagonal, then a Dirac field ##\Psi## can be written as a left-handed Weyl field ##\chi## stacked on top of a right-handed Weyl field ##\xi^\dagger##,
[tex]\Psi=\pmatrix{\chi\cr\xi^\dagger}[/tex]
The charge conjugate field is then
[tex]\Psi^c=\pmatrix{\xi\cr\chi^\dagger}[/tex]
Now if we set ##\xi=0##, then we recover Zee's statement (and your algebra). But I think it is more correct to say that the charge conjugate of the left-handed field ##\chi## is the left-handed field ##\xi##. Then, if we use ##\Psi## as a Dirac field for neutrinos, ##\chi## creates left-handed neutrinos, and ##\xi## creates left-handed antineutrinos, which is consistent with the wikipedia statement.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: silmaril89
Ok, thanks for the reply. I think I'm still a little confused, but you've put me in a particular direction to begin investigating this further.