Does gravitational energy travel like electrical energy?

In summary, the conversation discusses the transportation of electrical energy through a resistor and the idea that this may also apply to gravitational energy. However, the concept of energy transfer in a gravitational field is more elusive and difficult to determine. While there are some cases where energy may be transferred, such as through gravitational waves or the Penrose process, it is not as straightforward as in electromagnetism due to the lack of opposite charges and the difficulty of localizing energy in a gravitational field. Ultimately, the answer to whether gravitational energy travels in the same way as electrical energy is still unclear.
  • #1
Orthoceras
117
43
TL;DR Summary
Does gravitational energy travel like electrical energy?
Electrons flowing through a resistor are dissipating electrical energy. The electrical energy is transported from the battery to the electrons along the curved field lines of the Poynting vector. It seems like a meaningful idea that electrical energy necessarily travels from the source to the dissipation site.

My question is, does this idea somehow apply to gravitational energy as well? For example, consider a steady stream of sand falling through the air, from a funnel to the ground. Is the gravitational energy actually transported from the source (i.e., the funnel or the ground) to the dissipation site, where sand particles experience air resistance? If not, does gravitational energy not travel? Is gravitational energy more elusive than electrical energy?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
There are a lot of similarities between electromagnetism and gravity, but there are a lot of differences too. When thinking about flowing "charge" you have to remember that there are no opposite charges, so there's nothing quite like a current in a wire with a net zero charge. Also, like charges attract so the dynamics are rather different. Furthermore, localising energy in a gravitational field is notoriously difficult in all but the very simplest of circumstances, so it can prove very difficult to ask (rigorously) if energy has flowed anywhere.

So, as far as I understand it the "answer" to your query in general is that we don't really have a way to answer.

However, there are cases where you can argue that energy has transferred through the gravitational field. Gravitational waves are one such - Feynman pointed out that a pair of beads on a straight wire should move together and apart under the influence of a passing gravitational wave, and friction with the wire would generate heat, presumably sapping energy from the wave. And you can use the Penrose process to sap angular momentum from a black hole, again presumably passing energy through the field since there's nothing to touch.
 
  • Like
Likes malawi_glenn

1. How is gravitational energy different from electrical energy?

Gravitational energy is the potential energy stored in an object due to its position in a gravitational field, whereas electrical energy is the potential energy stored in an object due to the presence of electric charges.

2. Does gravitational energy move at the same speed as electrical energy?

No, gravitational energy does not travel in the same way as electrical energy. Gravitational energy is a form of potential energy and does not have a speed, while electrical energy is a form of kinetic energy and does have a speed.

3. Can gravitational energy be converted into electrical energy?

Yes, gravitational energy can be converted into electrical energy through the use of devices such as hydroelectric dams or tidal power plants. These devices harness the potential energy of water in a gravitational field and convert it into electrical energy.

4. Does gravitational energy follow the same laws as electrical energy?

No, gravitational energy follows different laws than electrical energy. Gravitational energy is governed by Newton's law of universal gravitation, while electrical energy follows the laws of electromagnetism.

5. Can gravitational energy be harnessed and used as a source of energy?

Currently, we do not have the technology to directly harness and use gravitational energy as a source of energy. However, we can indirectly harness it through other forms of energy conversion, such as using the potential energy of falling objects to generate electricity.

Similar threads

  • Classical Physics
Replies
16
Views
3K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
3
Views
919
Replies
14
Views
1K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
6
Views
612
Replies
1
Views
566
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
828
Replies
100
Views
6K
Replies
4
Views
853
Back
Top