Doesn't relativity define time as an illusion?

In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of time as a four-dimensional construct in the physical world, with three dimensions of space and one dimension of time. The past, present, and future are predetermined and time is not viewed as a flow, but rather a constant existence. The idea of time as an illusion is debated, with potential explanations being related to entropy, information theory, and cosmology.
  • #1
zeromodz
246
0
Like everything is in 4 dimensions. The 3 spatial ones and time. The past, future and present are already determined and just waiting to happen. There is no flow of time. What are your opinions on time, and what about a block time universe? How can time not be a flow, don't you need time in between each snapshot?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
An observer is a worldline in spacetime. Along his worldline, proper time, which is read by atomic clocks, passes. The difference from Newtonian time is that it is not universal, each observer has his own time.
 
  • #3
To answer your question no. The four dimensional solid you talk about is a mathematical construct. Here in the physical world there only exists an infinitesimal thin sheet with three large dimensions (spacial) and one infinitesimal (time).
 
  • #4
an interesting and deep question. Relativity does indeed force us to view the universe as a four-dimensional space-time manifold.

Thus, time apparently doesn't flow, it simply "is."

Whether you should now choose to describe time or the flow of time as an "illusion" is up for debate. Certainly psychologically the flow of time is certainly very tricky; we can be fooled. But should we describe the disconnect between the physical descriptions of time and our internal experiences as an Illusion? maybe.

It is thought that the possible physical bases of a "direction in time" may some day explain why we experience a forward flow. Current work relates to Entropy, information theory, as well as cosmological explanations.
 

FAQ: Doesn't relativity define time as an illusion?

1. What is relativity and how does it define time?

Relativity is a scientific theory proposed by Albert Einstein in the early 20th century that explains the relationships between space and time. According to relativity, time is not a fixed and absolute concept, but rather depends on the observer's frame of reference.

2. How does relativity suggest that time is an illusion?

Relativity suggests that time is an illusion because it is relative and not absolute. Time can appear to pass differently for different observers depending on their relative motion and proximity to massive objects. This means that time is not a constant, but rather a flexible concept.

3. Does this mean that time does not exist?

No, relativity does not suggest that time does not exist. It simply means that time is not a fixed and universal concept. Time still plays a crucial role in our everyday lives and is a fundamental part of the universe.

4. How does relativity impact our understanding of time?

Relativity has greatly impacted our understanding of time by challenging the traditional notion of time as a constant and absolute concept. It has also helped us understand the effects of gravity and motion on time and has led to the development of technologies such as GPS that rely on the principles of relativity.

5. Are there any experiments that have proven relativity's concept of time?

Yes, there have been numerous experiments that have confirmed the predictions of relativity regarding time. One famous example is the Hafele-Keating experiment, which used atomic clocks to measure the effects of time dilation caused by high speed and gravity. These experiments have provided evidence for the validity of relativity's concept of time.

Similar threads

Replies
32
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
7K
Replies
57
Views
3K
Replies
106
Views
7K
Replies
74
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
131
Views
10K
Back
Top