Drawing resonance structure for this O-CH2 ion

2 replies · 3K views · last reply
Sunwoo Bae
Messages
60
Reaction score
4
Homework Statement
For the ion shown below, draw the most important resonance forms and predict which resonance form is likely to be the major contributor.
Relevant Equations
none
ion shown:
Skeletal structure of a cyclohexadienone ring with a C=O group at the top and a negatively charged CH2 carbanion (C with a minus sign, then CH2) attached to the ring carbon at the lower right.


My answer:
Hand-drawn resonance structures of a phenoxide-type anion with a CH2 carbanion substituent on a benzene ring, bracketed, with three double-headed resonance arrows and the rightmost structure labelled major component.


the following is the answer of the question:
Three resonance structures of a cyclohexadienone anion with a CH2 exocyclic methylene group; curved arrows move electron pairs, and the rightmost structure, a phenoxide-type anion with the O- and CH2 drawn in red, is the one highlighted.


I identified the major contributor correctly, but the resonance structures, but the second resonance I drew is missing in the answer sheet.
Can anyone tell me why the second resonance structure is not part of the answer?

Thank you
 
Same reason as before. Question asks for the most important resonance forms, not every possible one.
 
There would be quite many hexagons to draw, if you drew every single one.

edited for grammar