Dynamics (mechanics) and virtual work

In summary, virtual work is a restatement of static equilibrium where we add up all the forces to get zero. It is important because it is the way to state the equilibrium condition for a system with constraints.
  • #1
luis20
50
0
Hi everyone, I'm studying applied dynamics for college.

I have a simple question and then a more importante question:

F=dq/dt=ma
(torque)T=dL/dt

What do you call these equations, Newton-euler equations?
I use these equations all the time to relate forces and torques with motion, in certain mechanisms.

But suddenly, the principle of virtual work appears.
I think that virtual work is nothing more than a deduction of the previous equations, where we do F-ma=0 and T-dL/dt=0 and multiply by any displacement, since 0*displacement=0.
I heard that virtual work is used a lot! But I can't get it, what does virtual work bring new?

Another question of curiosity, virtual work was used at the beggining for static or dynamic?

Thanks a lot for the answers
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Luis, I agree with you, the discussion given in most mechanics texts makes a mystery out of virtual work. It's usually skimmed over quickly, and it seems so obvious, why would anyone make a deal about it? Because in addition to being useful in its own right, it's a stepping stone on the path from Newton's laws of motion to Lagrange's equations.

The principle of virtual work is basically a restatement of static equilibrium. We know the condition is that the resultant force on each particle is zero: Ri = 0. So first we just add them all together and get this: δW = ∑ Ri·δri = 0 where δri are arbitrary virtual displacements. As you point out, this is trivial, adding up a bunch of zeroes to get zero.

Things get more interesting however if the system is subject to constraints, because then the displacements δri are not all independent. What to do in that case? Answer: we split the forces into applied forces Fa and constraint forces Fc: Ri = Fai + Fci. If we only allow virtual displacements that are compatible with the constraints, the constraining forces can't do any work: ∑ Fci·δri = 0. What we are left with is a relationship that involves just the applied forces, ∑ Fai·δri = 0. This is the Principle of Virtual Work.

Still looks almost the same, so why is it important? Because it's the way to state the equilibrium condition for a system with constraints. Since the δri are not independent, it is no longer true that the forces Fai are separately zero.
 
  • #3
Thanks for the explanation!

I didn't understand your last paragraph. What you mean with equilibrium condition?

Anyway, everything we can conclude with virtual work, we can also conclude with Newton's laws right? So it just may be easier to use virtual work if, as you said, the virtual displacement is compatible with some of the constraint forces.

But friction, if it is a constraint force, does work in some situations...
 
Last edited:
  • #4
everything we can conclude with virtual work, we can also conclude with Newton's laws right?
Doing it with Newton's Laws requires you to calculate all the forces including the constraint forces. Whereas doing it with virtual work you only need to deal with the external forces, so you've reduced the size of the problem.
But friction, if it is a constraint force, does work in some situations...
Yes, this method only works for rigid constraints.
I didn't understand your last paragraph. What you mean with equilibrium condition?
Virtual work is an expression of static equilibrium - nothing moves.
 
  • #5
Bill_K said:
Doing it with Newton's Laws requires you to calculate all the forces including the constraint forces. Whereas doing it with virtual work you only need to deal with the external forces, so you've reduced the size of the problem.

Right. Yet, we can apply virtual displacements not compatible with some of constraint forces, so they will "do work" in that case right, even though they are rigid constraints?

Like a block attached to the floor and I apply a δy, so all goes up (in this case wouldn't be useful :)
 

Related to Dynamics (mechanics) and virtual work

1. What is dynamics (mechanics) and virtual work?

Dynamics (mechanics) is a branch of physics that studies the motion and forces of objects. Virtual work is a mathematical concept that describes the work done by a force on a system.

2. How is virtual work used in dynamics?

Virtual work is used in dynamics to calculate the forces and motion of a system without having to consider all the individual forces acting on each object in the system. It allows for simplified calculations and analysis of complex systems.

3. What is the principle of virtual work?

The principle of virtual work states that the work done by all the forces acting on a system is equal to the change in the virtual potential energy of the system. This principle is often used in dynamic systems to find the equilibrium position and forces acting on an object.

4. What is the difference between virtual work and actual work?

Virtual work refers to the work done by a force on a system without actually moving the system. It is a mathematical concept used for analysis and calculations. Actual work, on the other hand, is the physical displacement of an object due to a force acting on it.

5. How is virtual work important in engineering and physics?

Virtual work is an important concept in engineering and physics as it allows for the analysis and design of complex systems. It is used in various fields such as structural engineering, robotics, and mechanics to optimize designs and predict the behavior of systems under different conditions.

Similar threads

Replies
22
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
2
Views
949
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
658
Replies
4
Views
876
Replies
4
Views
1K
Back
Top