Edge predictions related to QG

  • Thread starter Thread starter marcus
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Edge
marcus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
Dearly Missed
Messages
24,753
Reaction score
794
http://edge.org/q2009/q09_index.html

At least one of this year's "big change coming" predictions had to do with quantum gravity. I'd like to collect links to those with some bearing on QG, if there are others.
The one I just read, which impressed me as reasonably likely to happen and described in a fair amount of detail, was by cosmologist Paul Steinhardt. He seems to be leaning more towards the LQG cyclic picture these days (black hole big bang bounce, instead of brane-clash).
If you find more, please post links! There are too many replies to the 2009 Edge question for anyone person to go thru.:approve:

Here is the Paul Steinhardt prediction:
http://edge.org/q2009/q09_3.html#steinhardt
==================

Eventually I went thru the list, realizing that others might not get around to it any time soon. Perhaps I missed some but I could only find one other that either clearly or by some stretch had a bearing on QG:
http://edge.org/q2009/q09_9.html#smolinBoth these essays happened to draw a connection between cosmology and evolution---groping towards a coherent naturalistic cosmo-evo worldview.
I have to confess to disappointment: only two out of 150, and the sole hard-core QG forecast was the one by Paul Steinhardt---at least that I could find.

===================
The forecast I found most enjoyable was a short paragraph about kite-surfing included in Garrett Lisi's essay.
 
Last edited:
I seem to notice a buildup of papers like this: Detecting single gravitons with quantum sensing. (OK, old one.) Toward graviton detection via photon-graviton quantum state conversion Is this akin to “we’re soon gonna put string theory to the test”, or are these legit? Mind, I’m not expecting anyone to read the papers and explain them to me, but if one of you educated people already have an opinion I’d like to hear it. If not please ignore me. EDIT: I strongly suspect it’s bunk but...
Back
Top