Electric field of concentric rings

2 replies · 4K views · last reply
cookiemnstr510510
Messages
162
Reaction score
14

Homework Statement


Derive the electric field a distance, z, above the center of a single uniformly charged ring of radius, R, with a linear charge density, λ. You are now given two uniformly charged concentric rings. The inner ring has radius, R, and carries a uniformly distributed total charge +[Q]. The outer ring has radius 3R and carries a uniform charge per length, λ. If the resulting electric field from the two rings is zero at an axial height of z=2R above the centers of the two rings, determine the value of λ.

Im wondering if I've solved for λ correctly

Homework Equations


All relevant equations and work are attached in with clean typed images/work

The Attempt at a Solution


All relevant equations and work are attached in with clean typed images/work

Thanks
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten-style typed derivation of the electric field of a uniformly charged ring: dE = KQ/r^2, dEx = KQ/r^2 cos θ, cos θ = z/sqrt(z^2+R^2), r = sqrt(z^2+R^2), λ = Q/L, dq = λdl, k = 9x10^9 Nm^2/C^2, and integrals of dEx over 0 to 2piR giving KQz/(z^2+R^2)^3/2, followed by part b notes about an outer ring at distance 3R and zero field at z=2R.
    Concentric Ring 1.png
    28.1 KB · Views: 675
  • Typed derivation of the axial electric field of a uniformly charged ring, with E2 for ring 2 integrated as dEx = Kdq2R over ((2R)^2+R^2)^(3/2), leading to E2 = KλR2πR over ((2R)^2+R^2)^(3/2), then E1 = -E2 and λ = -Q((2R)^2+R^2)^(3/2) over 2πR.
    Concentric Ring 2.png
    16.7 KB · Views: 703
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
I think you have a mistake in the calculation of ##E_2##. The denominator should be ##{((2R)^2+(3R)^2)}^{3/2}##.

But I see no reason why you repeat the calculation. I mean you already found that the electric field at distance z above the centre due to a uniformed charged ring of radius R . Just apply this result for radius R=3R (if I can write it that way but I guess you ll understand what I mean).
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: cookiemnstr510510
Delta² said:
I think you have a mistake in the calculation of ##E_2##. The denominator should be ##{((2R)^2+(3R)^2)}^{3/2}##.

But I see no reason why you repeat the calculation. I mean you already found that the electric field at distance z above the centre due to a uniformed charged ring of radius R . Just apply this result for radius R=3R (if I can write it that way but I guess you ll understand what I mean).
Ahhh okay, yes you're correct. okay, Ill try that out and see what λ I get
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2