Electrostatic Force and Field between two charges

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
psy
Messages
13
Reaction score
1
Two positive point charges with a charge of 10nC each are 10cm apart. What is the electric field strength at point A? How is it directed? Which force acts on a charge of 100nC at point A?
Diagram of two positive point charges, q1 = 10 nC and q2 = 10 nC, with point A midway below them at distance r from each, with field vectors E1, E2 and forces Fe1, Fe2, Fe and the label l2 = 5cm.
F = k * q1 * q2 / r^2
E = F/q
r^2 = (l1/2)^2 + (l2)^2 => r = 0,707m

Electric field strength :

E1 = E2 = 8.99 x 10^9 Nm^2/C^2 * 10*10^-9C / (0,707m)^2 = 179,854 N/C So i "pulled apart" the Electric field strength in x and y components.
Diagram of a black point charge with arrows showing field vectors E1 and E2 pointing away at 45 degrees, their x-components E1x and E2x pointing horizontally, and y-components E1y and E2y pointing downward.

E1y = E1 * cos(45°)= 127,176 N/C
E2y = E2 * cos(45°)=127,176 N/C
E1x = E1 * sin(45°) = 127, 176 N/C
E2x = E2* sin(45°) = 127, 176 N/C

As the Field strength components have the same Amount, yet oppose direction they substract themselvs to Zero, E1y-E2y = 0 ; E1x-E2x = 0. So the Overall Field strength in Point A is Zero.

At the second part i suppose to calculate the Electric Force, if at Point A is a Charge q3= 100nC.
Fe1 = k * q1 * q3 / r^2 = 1,7985*10^-5 N
Fe2 = k * q1 * q3 / r^2 = 1,7985*10^-5 N.

The Overall force Fe^2 = Fe1^2 + Fe2 ^2 => Fe = 2,54 * 10^-5.

Is this the right way to calculate it? I am open for every Suggestion.

Kind Regards
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of two black point charges, each labelled q1 = 10 nC, placed 10 cm apart on a horizontal line, with point A 5 cm below the midpoint of the line.
    upload_2018-5-6_14-22-25.png
    2.3 KB · Views: 552
  • Diagram of two positive point charges, each labelled q1 = 10 nC, 10 cm apart on a horizontal line; point A lies 5 cm below their midpoint, with r marked as the straight line from the left charge to A.
    upload_2018-5-6_14-24-54.png
    2.5 KB · Views: 546
  • Diagram of two equal positive point charges labelled q1 = 10 nC, 10 cm apart, with point A below the midpoint forming an isosceles triangle; l2 = 5 cm is marked from the midline to A and r from one charge to A.
    upload_2018-5-6_14-30-48.png
    3 KB · Views: 546
  • Diagram of two positive point charges q1 = 10 nC and q2 = 10 nC on a horizontal line 10 cm apart, with point A at the midpoint below. Arrows show distance r to A, forces Fe1 and Fe2 pointing away from each charge, and the net force Fe pointing straight down.
    upload_2018-5-6_14-36-15.png
    3.7 KB · Views: 506
  • Diagram of two positive point charges q1 = 10 nC and q2 = 10 nC separated by l1 = 10 cm, with point A 5 cm below the midpoint; forces Fe1, Fe2 and Fe are drawn at A along with distance r.
    upload_2018-5-6_14-36-55.png
    4.3 KB · Views: 563
  • Diagram of two positive charges q1 = 10 nC and q2 = 10 nC separated by l1 = 10 cm, with point A 5 cm below the midpoint; distances r to A and force vectors Fe1, Fe2 and Fe are drawn.
    upload_2018-5-6_14-39-44.png
    4.3 KB · Views: 538
  • Diagram of two positive point charges, q1 = 10 nC and q2 = 10 nC, with point A midway below them at distance r from each, with field vectors E1, E2 and forces Fe1, Fe2, Fe and the label l2 = 5cm.
    upload_2018-5-6_14-55-39.png
    3.8 KB · Views: 995
  • Diagram of a black point charge with arrows showing field vectors E1 and E2 pointing away at 45 degrees, their x-components E1x and E2x pointing horizontally, and y-components E1y and E2y pointing downward.
    upload_2018-5-6_15-39-14.png
    1.3 KB · Views: 453
psy said:
As the Field strength components have the same Amount, yet oppose direction they substract themselvs to Zero, E1y-E2y = 0 ; E1x-E2x = 0. So the Overall Field strength in Point A is Zero.
I can see that E1x and E2x are opposite and add to zero. Why do the y components add to zero? There is a problem in how you are treating the components. The components of a vector are algebraic quantities. E1x and E2x do not have the same sign.
For the second part, the two forces on the point charge at the point A are vectors. They should be added as vectors. You added their magnitudes. Your diagram is showing the forces correctly, but you did ot follow it up with the correct method of vector addition.
 
Hello

So i have made the following correction:

r= 0,0707m

E1 = E2 = 17985,4 N/C

E1y = E1 * cos(-45°)= 12717,6 N/C
E2y = E2 * cos(45°)=12717,6 N/C
E1x = E1 * sin(-45°) = -12717,6 N/C
E2x = E2* sin(45°) = 12717,6 N/C

Ey = E1y+E2y = 25435.2 N/C
Ex = E1x+ E2x = -12717,6 N/C+12717,6 N/C = 0.

So the Electric field strength is E = Ey + Ex = 25435.2 N/C + 0 = 25435.2 N/C

In the second part, for calculating the force in case there is a 100nC Point Charge at the given spot :

F= q*E =100*10^-9C * 25435.2 N/C = 25,43* 10^-3 N.

Is this the correct way?

Kind Regards
 
You should really read up about how to add and subtract vectors from your textbook. For any vector V (bold font)
V ≠ Vx + Vy
The left hand side is a vector, with a direction. The components on the right hand side are not vectors. They are algebraic quantities. You must use either unit vectors, or specify both magnitude and direction to write a vector.