Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the use of FeynArts and FormCalc programs in particle physics calculations, specifically regarding the interpretation of parameters such as CKM[Gen4, 3] and SumOver[Gen4, 3] in the context of processes like b → s γ. Participants are exploring the implications of these parameters and seeking clarification on their meanings and expected behavior in calculations.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation, Conceptual clarification, Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant seeks clarification on the meaning and values of CKM[Gen4, 3] and SumOver[Gen4, 3] in their calculations.
- Another participant explains that CKM[Gen4, 3] indicates a sum over Gen4, suggesting that the "4" is an internal counter and that the sum runs over indices 1 to 3.
- This explanation includes a reference to the FFV triangle diagram and the need to sum contributions from different generations of quarks.
- A different participant expresses concern that FeynArts should not display these symbols in the final result, indicating a potential issue or bug in the program.
- Another participant questions how the results of CreateFeynAmp are being treated, suggesting that the parameters should appear in the results and that the diagram created from InsertFields represents a sum over various internal freedoms.
- One participant inquires about the capabilities of FeynCalc for loop-level calculations, comparing it to CalcHep.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
There is no clear consensus on the interpretation of the parameters or the functioning of the programs, as participants express differing views on the expected behavior of FeynArts and the handling of results.
Contextual Notes
Participants mention potential issues with the output of FeynArts and the interpretation of internal indices, indicating that there may be missing assumptions or unresolved details regarding the calculations.