Find distance proton moves between adjacent turns of helix

  • Thread starter Thread starter jburt
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Helix Proton
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves a proton moving in a magnetic field, specifically calculating the radius of the helix formed by its path and the distance between adjacent turns of the helix. The context includes concepts from electromagnetism and circular motion.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the calculation of the radius using the formula involving the magnetic force and the velocity component of the proton. There are questions about whether the correct velocity component is being used for calculations related to circular motion.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided calculations for the radius and time for a complete circle, while others express uncertainty about the assumptions made regarding the velocity components. There is an ongoing exploration of the relationship between the forces acting on the proton and the resulting motion.

Contextual Notes

Participants note potential discrepancies in the calculations and question the assumptions regarding the speed of the proton in the x-direction versus its overall speed. There is mention of specific values and equations used, but no consensus on the correct approach has been reached.

jburt
Messages
9
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A proton moves with a speed of 4300 m/s in a direction 76.0° above positive x axis. It enters a region where a magnetic filed of 25x10^-6 Tesla exists in the positive x direction. Find the radius of the helix formed by the protons path and the distance between adjacent turns of helix.

To find the distance, I'm not sure. I know I need to find distance around and time it takes for a complete circle.


Homework Equations



Force of mag. field = qvsin∅B
F=qvsin∅B=ma
F= qvsin∅B = mv^2/r

r = mvsin∅/ qB

v = 2∏r/t

t = 2∏r/v


xf=xi + vt
vyfinal = vyinitial + at



The Attempt at a Solution



r = (1.67*10^-27 * 4300sin76°) / (1.602*10^-19 * 25*10^-6)
r = 1.74m


t = 2∏r/v
t = .002542s

so, vyfinal = vyinitial + at

xf = 0 + 4300m/s(.002542m)

xf = 10.9, which is NOT the answer.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
jburt said:

Homework Statement


A proton moves with a speed of 4300 m/s in a direction 76.0° above positive x axis. It enters a region where a magnetic filed of 25x10^-6 Tesla exists in the positive x direction. Find the radius of the helix formed by the protons path and the distance between adjacent turns of helix.

To find the distance, I'm not sure. I know I need to find distance around and time it takes for a complete circle.


Homework Equations



Force of mag. field = qvsin∅B
F=qvsin∅B=ma
F= qvsin∅B = mv^2/r

r = mvsin∅/ qB

v = 2∏r/t

t = 2∏r/v


xf=xi + vt
vyfinal = vyinitial + at



The Attempt at a Solution



r = (1.67*10^-27 * 4300sin76°) / (1.602*10^-19 * 25*10^-6)
r = 1.74m
Okay, you've used the velocity of the particle that is perpendicular to the field. Good. That should give you the correct radius.
t = 2∏r/v
t = .002542s
Something fishy here. Did you use the speed of the particle rather than its velocity component in the (moving) plane of the loop? Hint: The speed of the particle in the loop should be the same as that which was used in the calculation of the loop radius.
 
so I have Δy=vsin∅t + at^2

Δy= 2∏r

but vsin∅final = vsin∅initial + at

F = ma

qvsin∅B = ma

a = qvsin∅B/m

a = (25*10^-6T)(4300sin76m/s)(1.602*10^-19C)/ (1.67*10^-27kg) = 1.0006*10^7
t = vsin∅final/a = 4172.27/1.0006*10^7 = .000417s

xfinal = vinitial*t = 4300m/s*.000417s =1.793m but it's wrong according to my professors answers. 8-(
 
Last edited:
jburt said:
so I have Δy=vsin∅t + at^2

Δy= 2∏r

but vsin∅final = vsin∅initial + at
Can you add some explanation to the above formulas? What acceleration are you dealing with? As far as I can tell the only acceleration you need to worry about is that involved with the circular motion -- centripetal acceleration.
F = ma

qvsin∅B = ma

a = qvsin∅B/m

a = (25*10^-6T)(4300sin76m/s)(1.602*10^-19C)/ (1.67*10^-27kg) = 1.0006*10^7
t = vsin∅final/a = 4172.27/1.0006*10^7 = .000417s
I think you're missing a factor of ##2\pi## in the above calculation.
xfinal = vinitial*t = 4300m/s*.000417s =1.793m but it's wrong according to my professors answers. 8-(
The proton does not have the full speed of 4300m/s in the x-direction.
 

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
14K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
5K
Replies
1
Views
6K
Replies
2
Views
5K
Replies
28
Views
16K