Find the correct value of the mean in the given problem

  • Thread starter chwala
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Mean Value
4 replies · 2K views · last reply
chwala
Gold Member
Messages
2,854
Reaction score
436
Homework Statement
See attached.
Relevant Equations
Statistics
Find the problem and solution below;
Printed problem text: An ordinary dice was thrown 50 times and the resulting scores summarised in a frequency table. The mean score was calculated to be 3.42. It was later found that the frequencies 12 and 9, of two consecutive scores, had been swapped. What is the correct value of the mean?
Printed textbook problem 10: Change by + or -0.06 depending on the order of the frequencies.


Now the part i do not seem to understand from the given solution is the negative value i.e to be specific ##-0.06##
In my understanding we shall have ##5## possibilities with each giving the correct mean value of ##3.48## which implies ##+0.06## from the given value on the text unless they meant ##3.48- 0.06=3.42##
They also did not indicate the correct value of the mean rather the difference.

My approach to the solution is as follows;

Consider the consecutive scores##1=12## and ##2=9## then it follows that the correct value of the mean will be given by;

##(171-30)+1(9)+2(12)=174##

##\dfrac{174}{50}=3.48##Consider the consecutive scores##2=12## and ##3=9## then it follows that the correct value of the mean will be given by;

##(171-51)+2(9)+3(12)=174##

##\dfrac{174}{50}=3.48##Consider the consecutive scores##3=12## and ##4=9## then it follows that the correct value of the mean will be given by;

##(171-72)+3(9)+4(12)=174##

##\dfrac{174}{50}=3.48##

Consider the consecutive scores##4=12## and ##5=9## then it follows that the correct value of the mean will be given by;

##(171-93)+4(9)+5(12)=174##

##\dfrac{174}{50}=3.48##

Consider the consecutive scores##5=12## and ##6=9## then it follows that the correct value of the mean will be given by;

##(171-114)+5(9)+6(12)=174##

##\dfrac{174}{50}=3.48##

Of course i would appreciate any other better approach. Cheers guys.
 
Attachments
  • Printed textbook exercise 10: Change by + or -0.06 depending on the order of the frequencies.
    1660488856153.png
    13.7 KB · Views: 203
What if, e.g, it says 5=9 and 6=12 and then you had to swap them (so the opposite direction of your post)
 
You could have used a variable, n, in your method:
Suppose the incorrect calculation included Incorrect=12n + 9(n+1) = 21n+9. Then the correct calculation would be Correct=9n+12(n+1) = 21n+12. The difference (removing the Incorrect and adding the Correct) would be -(21n+9)+(21n+12) = 3. That would change the final mean of the 50 samples by 3/50 = 0.06.
Now suppose the opposite mistake was made. A similar calculation says that the difference would be -3, giving a change of -3/50=-0.06.
 
Office_Shredder said:
What if, e.g, it says 5=9 and 6=12 and then you had to swap them (so the opposite direction of your post)
True, we shall have a mean value of ##3.36##Thanks.
 
FactChecker said:
You could have used a variable, n, in your method:
Suppose the incorrect calculation included Incorrect=12n + 9(n+1) = 21n+9. Then the correct calculation would be Correct=9n+12(n+1) = 21n+12. The difference (removing the Incorrect and adding the Correct) would be -(21n+9)+(21n+12) = 3. That would change the final mean of the 50 samples by 3/50 = 0.06.
Now suppose the opposite mistake was made. A similar calculation says that the difference would be -3, giving a change of -3/50=-0.06.
@FactChecker smart move there...