Finding the mean net force during a collision

3 replies · 3K views · last reply
youmei0426
Messages
18
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Multiple-choice physics question with a speed-time graph: speed is constant at u, drops to 0 at t1, then rises to v until t2, then stays at v. Answer options A to D give mean net force as m(u-v) or m(u+v) over (t2+t1) or (t2-t1).


Homework Equations


F=ma=mv/t[/B]

The Attempt at a Solution


I used the equation F=mv/t, in which I find the change in velocity and change in time before and after the collision. The change in time is t2-t1, but the problem comes when I am calculating the change in velocity. Shouldn't the change be (v-u)? The answer is D, in which the velocity becomes the sum of u and v, and I don't understand why. Thanks in advance!
 
Attachments
  • Multiple-choice physics question with a speed-time graph: speed is constant at u, drops to 0 at t1, then rises to v until t2, then stays at v. Answer options A to D give mean net force as m(u-v) or m(u+v) over (t2+t1) or (t2-t1).
    upload_2018-12-31_13-43-56.png
    14.7 KB · Views: 1,096
This is what it looks like visually:

Diagram of a ball of mass m moving right with velocity u toward a vertical wall, and rebounding left with velocity -v; an x axis points right along the floor.

As PhantomJay has stated, you need to actually understand what the equation you are using really means and what each of the variables are. The FULL equation here is:

[tex]\vec{F} = m \frac{\Delta \vec{v}}{\Delta t}[/tex]

Since velocity is a vector, the CHANGE in velocity will require that you know the directions of the initial and final velocity. If we designate +x direction as the same direction as "u" (as in the fig), then the final velocity is "-v".

This, Δv = -vi - ui = - (v+u)i;

and
Δt = t2 - t1

This means that the force exerted by the wall is

[tex]\vec{F} = -m \frac{v+u}{t_2 - t_1} \hat{i}[/tex]

The negative sign means that the force exerted BY the wall ONTO the mass is in the -x direction, i.e. to the left in the figure. The answer options in the question only care about the magnitude. But even so, as you can see, you can't ignore that these are vectors till the very end.

Moral of the story here is that you need to do this very carefully and to follow the "rules" meticulously. Otherwise, you'll get trapped with the signs issue.

Zz.
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a ball of mass m moving right with velocity u toward a vertical wall, and rebounding left with velocity -v; an x axis points right along the floor.
    wall.jpg
    6.4 KB · Views: 954
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: youmei0426