Finding unknown currents using Kirchhoff's current law at nodes

6 replies · 21K views · last reply
yaro99
Messages
75
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Determine the values of the other currents in Figure P1.37, given that ia = 2 A, ic =−3 A,
ig = 6A,and ih= 1A.

Circuit schematic labelled Figure P1.37 with eight boxed elements A to H arranged in a rectangular network, with currents ia, ib, ic, id, ie, if, ig and ih marked by arrows.



Homework Equations


∑currents entering a node = ∑currents exiting the node


The Attempt at a Solution



I used Kirchoff's Circuit Law on each of the outer nodes:

if = ig + ih = 6 + 1 = 7A

ia + id = if
2 + id = 7
id = 5A

ic + ih= ie
-3 + 1 = ie
ie = -2A

ib = ia + ic = 2 - 3 = -1A

I think I may have went wrong somewhere, because when I apply KCL to one of the inner nodes I get this:

ie + ig = id (?)
-2 + 6 ≠ 5
 
yaro99 said:

Homework Statement


Determine the values of the other currents in Figure P1.37, given that ia = 2 A, ic =−3 A,
ig = 6A,and ih= 1A.

Circuit schematic labelled Figure P1.37 with eight branches A to H arranged in a rectangular grid, each with a labelled current arrow: ia, ib, ic, id, ie, if, ig, ih.



Homework Equations


∑currents entering a node = ∑currents exiting the node


The Attempt at a Solution



I used Kirchoff's Circuit Law on each of the outer nodes:

if = ig + ih = 6 + 1 = 7A

ia + id = if
2 + id = 7
id = 5A

ic + ih= ie
-3 + 1 = ie
ie = -2A

ib = ia + ic = 2 - 3 = -1A

I think I may have went wrong somewhere, because when I apply KCL to one of the inner nodes I get this:

ie + ig = id (?)
-2 + 6 ≠ 5

There's only one "inner node" where B, D, G, and E meet; despite there being two connection dots there, they are all one single conducting path with no components in between.

So, your node equation needs to account for ##i_b##, too.
 
gneill said:
There's only one "inner node" where B, D, G, and E meet; despite there being two connection dots there, they are all one single conducting path with no components in between.

So, your node equation needs to account for ##i_b##, too.

Aha, in that case it will be
-2 + 6 = -1 + 5
4 = 4

How do I know that the node includes ##i_b##, is that current not affected by the current ##i_d##?

Is the point connecting B and D not a node?
 
The two inner nodes are actually one node.
You missed a current: two currents go into the node and two currents go out of the node.

[edit]gah: too slow!
 
yaro99 said:
How do I know that the node includes ##i_b##, is that current not affected by the current ##i_d##?

Is the point connecting B and D not a node?

So long as there is a continuous conducting path it is all one node. A node is not a dot on the diagram, it's the entire continuous conducting path.

To make it more clear, you can shift component E over a bit as follows:

Circuit schematic labeled Figure P1.37 showing eight two-terminal elements A to H in a rectangular network with branch currents ia, ib, ic, id, ie, if, ig and ik, a green-highlighted central wire joining the middle nodes.


The wiring in green is continuously connected, so it's all one node.
 
Attachments
  • Circuit schematic labelled Figure P1.37 with eight branches A to H arranged in a rectangular grid, with currents i_a to i_h marked by arrows, and elements D and E in the centre column; the central horizontal wire is shown in green.
    Fig1.gif
    3.5 KB · Views: 1,084
gneill said:
So long as there is a continuous conducting path it is all one node. A node is not a dot on the diagram, it's the entire continuous conducting path.

To make it more clear, you can shift component E over a bit as follows:

Circuit schematic labelled Figure P1.37 with eight boxed elements A to H arranged in a bridge-like network, with branch currents i_a, i_b, i_c, i_d, i_e, i_f, i_g and i_h marked by arrows.


The wiring in green is continuously connected, so it's all one node.

Ah, yes that confused me a bit. It makes sense now thanks!
 
Great - the other way to look at it is to add an extra current arrow ##\small{i_0}## in the gap between the "two" center nodes. You can tell which direction it has to point in by looking at the other currents - but it actually doesn't matter:

Current in = current out:
... so on the left node you get ##i_0 = i_b+i_d##
... and for the right node you get ##i_0=i_g+i_e##

... eliminate the ##\small{i_0}## term gives you ##i_b+i_d = i_g+i_e##

and it all comes out in the wash ;)

It's just easier to realize that the nodes for Kirkoffs laws actually include the entire wire between components. Thus two drawn node-symbols, on the diagram, that have no components between them, are one and the same.