Fix water-submerged electronic remote ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter irishetalon00
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Electronic
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the issue of a water-submerged electronic remote control, specifically exploring the potential causes of malfunction and the effects of a hard coating found on the circuit board after the incident. Participants share their experiences and hypotheses regarding the nature of the deposits and the implications for electronic repair.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes the initial incident with their remote, noting that after drying it out, it still failed to work, leading to an inspection where they found a hard coating at the base of the capacitors.
  • Another participant suggests that the coating might have been conductive enough to cause short circuits or parasitic effects.
  • A question is raised regarding why the deposits only formed around the capacitors and what role the spilled liquid played in this phenomenon.
  • Some participants propose that the hard coating could be a fault-causing substance or an incidental deposit that was disturbed during the cleaning process.
  • There is speculation that the deposits could be related to electrolytic capacitor leakage, although one participant expresses uncertainty about this connection.
  • One participant shares a personal experience of cleaning a remote and suggests that sugar or coffee residue could mimic a pushed button, complicating the circuit's functionality.
  • Another participant mentions their experience with dendrites forming on circuit boards under humidity, suggesting that scraping could have resolved the issue by breaking these conductive threads.
  • There is a mention of adhesive used in electronics that could also explain the hard coating observed.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express various hypotheses regarding the nature of the hard coating and its effects on the remote's functionality. No consensus is reached on the exact cause of the issue or the identity of the deposits, indicating multiple competing views remain.

Contextual Notes

Participants acknowledge the limitations of their analysis due to the lack of direct examination of the circuit board and the deposits. The discussion remains speculative regarding the exact chemical and physical interactions involved.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be of interest to individuals dealing with similar issues in electronic devices, particularly those curious about the effects of liquid exposure on circuit boards and potential repair methods.

irishetalon00
Messages
20
Reaction score
2
Fix water-submerged electronic remote!??!

I have an expensive (around $300) universal remote control that got water (I think? can't remember...some kind of beverage!) splashed on it about 2 years ago. When this happened, I immediately pulled the batteries and let it dry out for about a month. The next time I tried to turn it on, I put the batteries on and the thing beeped then just quit. Alas, I bought another one, but kept the old one hoping to get it fixed somehow/someday.

About a year ago (1 year after the incident), I tried booting it up again. Same problem.

Today, I decided to bust the thing open (it's built like an apple device, lots of hidden clips and stuff, practically no screws) and visually inspected it. After about 20-30 minutes of visual inspection I noticed a hard, clear coating at the base of all 4 capacitors. I tried picking at it, and with some effort it chipped off like plaque or something. The hard chips turned from clear to white as I was chipping. I was careful not to pull up or scratch any of the PCB conducting elements.

I threw the thing back together, and it WOfRKS! What in the world was that stuf, and why is it fixed after I picked it away??
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
without seeing the pcb's and the gunk you picked away its hard to tell. I'm guess the gunk probably has enough conductivity to short circuit a bit or create enough parasitic effects to mess up some signals.
 
But *if* this "depositing" actually was the perpetrator, then why did it only collect around the bases of the capacitors? If the hard deposits were part of the original design (pre-spillage), then what did the spilling do to these deposits to cause them to short/conduct/whatever-they-were-doing?
 
1. the hard stuff was something causing the fault and it was part of the water that just happened to like the capacitors ... without knowing what it is there is no way to tell why.

2. the hard stuff is incidental and the act of removing it also removed whatever was causing the fault - say a fine mineral salt deposit someplace that got shaken loose by the act of picking away the hard stuff.

You can check by opening the new one and comparing.
 
the stuff could also be stuff leaking out of your caps, assuming those are electrolytic capacitors
 
I always thought that the onset of electrolytic capacitor leakage meant component failure, and therefore the remote wouldn't work at all. And secondly the "stuff" that comes out of caps is usually like a dark brown, right?

I don't want to take the new one apart, as it never goes back together QUITE the same, and I'm rather obsessive about the feel of my buttons, etc.

I I just thought there might have been some kind of known electro-chemical reaction between the caps' charge (possibly alternating?) and the liquid.

Thanks for the posts guys!
 
without hands-on it's all speculation.
What you described sounds to me like "Conformal Coating", a varnish like stuff that they apply to boards to keep them from corroding .

Your trouble was likely conductive stuff dissolved in the drink that got spilt. It gets under the buttons. Those "soft" buttons are almost non-conductive but not quite. When you push them they make contact with the circuit board, the pads for that contact are not conformal-coated..
But it's not a zero ohm contact like a switch; the rubber switch pad is just enough less than infinity ohms that the board recognizes it as a pushed button.
Sugar or coffee residue on the board from a spilt drink can look electrically much like a pushed button. It may take years to completely dry and become non-conductive enough to let the board work again.

I got another six months out of my Dish TV remote by prying it apart, lifting the rubber button pad, cleaning both the pad and the circuit board with rubbing alcohol , then drying overnight on the fireplace. That advice I got here at PF.

Good luck !
 
jim hardy said:
I got another six months out of my Dish TV remote by prying it apart, lifting the rubber button pad, cleaning both the pad and the circuit board with rubbing alcohol , then drying overnight on the fireplace.

Note that he said on the fireplace, not in it; that would be counterproductive.
 
Danger said:
Note that he said on the fireplace, not in it; that would be counterproductive.

Well, actually that IS my last resort.
When it gets to the point I'm investing too much time in some old piece of junk, I turn it into winter BTU's which both warms the house and spares me further distraction.
 
  • #10
:smile:
 
  • #11
I used to work in quality where I tested products after accelerated life testing. One of the tests exposed the circuits to high humidity. When a unit failed, we checked the circuit board under a microscope for dendrites. These tiny metallic threads that grow between oppositely charged traces and are too thin to be seen without a microscope. They grow rapidly enough to be seen growing under the microscope. Sometimes when we couldn't find the dendrite we'd scrape between traces of opposite polarity and usually the problem disappeared.

This is what I think happened to your control and in the process of all the scraping you did, you broke the dendrites.
 
Last edited:
  • #12
Option 2 post #4 looking good then?
Actually this reminds me of when I was repairing old electronics - the fix was very often just to run a screwdriver between tracks on the circuit-board near components - particularly capacitors. Now I think I see why it worked.
 
  • #13
The "hard stuff" is also more likely to be some sort of adhesive
often used to keep electro caps and other coponents in place
to avoid them working loose with vibration and their solder joints becoming dry jointed

Dave
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
5K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
14K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
4K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
7K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
1K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
9K
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K