Force between two perpendicular wires

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
Eitan Levy
Messages
259
Reaction score
11
Homework Statement
In a system as described in the picture, what would be the force that the infinite wire with a current of i exerts on the wire BC?
Relevant Equations
F=BILsinΘ
μThe magnetic field is supposed to be B=μ0i/(2πr). I think that the force would be aimed upwards.

Now I tried to divide the wire BC to infinite smaller wires where B is roughly constant in each one of them.

What I get is:
Equation: F = ∫dF = I∫B × dl = I ∫ from r=r_B to r=r_C of (μ0 * i)/(2πr) * dr = (μ0 * I * i)/(2π) * ln(r_C/r_B).

However this is not correct when I plug the relevant numbers in it.

Where is my mistake?
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a rectangular-ish loop ABCDEF carrying current I in the presence of a long straight wire carrying current i to its left, with a grid of into-page magnetic field crosses inside the loop and dots outside; distance R marked between wire and point A.
    Capture.PNG
    15.5 KB · Views: 355
Your work looks basically correct.

Equation: F vector = integral of dF vector = I integral of B vector cross dl vector, all vector quantities in LaTeX-style notation.

I think there's a sign error on the right-hand side. Is the force ##\vec{dF}## in the same direction as ##\vec B \times \vec{dl}##? I assume that you are using the usual convention that ##\vec{dl}## is in the same direcrion as the current in ##dl##.

Handwritten-style equation: I times the integral of B-vector cross dl-vector equals I times the integral from r = r_B to r = r_C of mu_0 times i over 2 pi r, times dr.

The left side is a vector quantity while the right side is a scalar quantity. So, you should include a unit vector on the right side to indicate the direction of the quantity on the left side.

Your final result looks correct for the magnitude of the force on BC. Were you also expected to give the direction of the force?
 
How do you know that you plugged in the numbers correctly? Show us the numbers and exactly what you did. Also, the force is ##d\vec F=Id\vec l \times \vec B##. You show the negative of this.
 
I indeed plugged the numbers wrong. Thanks for the heads up about the wrong direction of dF, I will be more careful.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: TSny