Friction Coefficients: Determining Force Direction?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on determining force direction based on friction coefficients, specifically comparing mu_b and mu_a. It is established that if mu_b is greater than mu_a, block B will be pushed forward while block A is pushed backward, regardless of their masses. Participants emphasize the importance of free body diagrams and suggest that comparing coefficients of friction can simplify analysis. It is noted that while one can assume an arbitrary direction for force, the sign of the magnitude is crucial for understanding the actual direction of the force. The conversation highlights a common analytical approach in friction problems involving inclined planes.
link223
Messages
70
Reaction score
12
Homework Statement
Blocks A and B of mass 13 kg and 10 kg respectively, are placed on the inclined plane and released. The coefficients of kinetic friction between the blocks and the inclined plane are μA=0.2 and μB=0.5 . Neglect the mass of the link.


Determine the magnitude of the force developed in the link.
Relevant Equations
nothing special.
Do I determine this from the friction coefficients?
Such that because mu_b > mu_a I know that it'll push on B because it has a bigger friction coefficient.
such that this has nothing to do with the mass of the blocks? or does it?

f.e. can I take it to be in an arbitrary direction and then solve the equations of motion for both and find the magnitude of the force in the link that way?
I did it but I might've ran an error in the analysis. I did it the other way around aka looking at it as mu_b>mu_a such that it pushes B forward and A backwards and I got the correct answer.
appreciated.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
1659115950312.png
 
What do you know about friction on an inclined plane? You have a formula for it?
 
  • Like
Likes link223
malawi_glenn said:
What do you know about friction on an inclined plane? You have a formula for it?
sure thing.
for B ##F_b = 42.48n##
for A ##F_a = 22.1n##
and this concludes that it will push on B and not pull it gadaimm
 
Where are your free body diagrams?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes malawi_glenn
If you are asking if you can just compare the coefficients of friction for this type of problem, it does appear to be that way. If block ##A## has the lower COF it will push on block ##B## putting the link in compression. If block ##B## has the lower COF it will pull on block ##A## putting the link in tension. Thats seems generally true for this specific type of problem ( I wasn't aware of this "shortcut" before you suggested it though).
 
Last edited:
link223 said:
can I take it to be in an arbitrary direction and then solve the equations of motion for both and find the magnitude of the force in the link that way?
Yes, you should not need to predict the direction of force, but finding the magnitude won't do it since you will need the sign to tell you which way it acts. You probably didn't mean that.
Please post that attempt if you'd like to find where you went wrong.
 
Back
Top