Discussion Overview
The discussion centers around recommendations for multivariable calculus textbooks, with participants sharing their opinions on various books and expressing dissatisfaction with certain texts currently in use.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Technical explanation
Main Points Raised
- One participant expresses strong dissatisfaction with "Multivariable Calculus" by James Stewart, comparing it unfavorably to his single variable calculus book.
- Another participant suggests "Vector Calculus" by Marsden and Tromba as a potential alternative.
- A third participant recommends "Advanced Calculus of Several Variables" by C. H. Edwards without elaborating on its merits.
- One participant questions what specific aspects of Stewart's book are disliked, suggesting "Kaplan, Advanced Calculus" and "Mathematical Methods In The Physical Sciences" by Mary L. Boas as useful alternatives.
- A later reply mentions "volume 2 of Apostol" as another potential resource, though it is unclear what specific needs it addresses.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not appear to reach a consensus on the quality of Stewart's book, with some expressing strong negative opinions while others suggest it has its merits. Multiple competing recommendations for alternative texts are presented, indicating a lack of agreement on a single preferred book.
Contextual Notes
Participants have not provided detailed criteria for what constitutes a "good" multivariable calculus book, nor have they specified the aspects of Stewart's book that are problematic. The discussion reflects a range of personal preferences and experiences with different texts.
Who May Find This Useful
Students seeking alternatives to commonly used multivariable calculus textbooks, educators looking for recommendations, and anyone interested in mathematical methods in the physical sciences may find this discussion relevant.
