GR- Energy conservation, effective potential graph sketch

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
binbagsss
Messages
1,291
Reaction score
12

Homework Statement


Typeset problem statement: metric ds^2 = -(r - 1/r)dt^2 + (r - 1/r)^-1 dr^2 + r^2(dtheta^2 + sin^2 theta dphi^2), with parts (a) to (d) on Killing constants, geodesic potential, null orbits and timelike sketch.


I would like to ask about parts c) and d) , the graph sketching bits.


2. Homework Equations


##V(r) = ( \frac{J^2}{r^2}+\epsilon)(r-\frac{1}{r}) ##

where the value of ## \epsilon ## is set according to whether time-like or null etc.

The Attempt at a Solution



Q1)for part c)

##V(r) = ( \frac{J^2}{r^2})(r-\frac{1}{r}) ##

I am able to deduce the shape of the curve from the fact that the potential ##V'(r)=0 ## is a quadratic and solveable, and so i can check whether this is a stable or unstable point. So to sketch I:
a) ## \lim r \to \infty ## and ## \lim r\to 0 ##
b) to deduce the cts shape consider the critical point and check whether it is stable or unstable.
and that gives me the following which is fine.

(giving me the following:
Handwritten working on grid paper: null geodesics case epsilon = 0 with V(r) = (J^2/r^2)(r - 1/r), limits as r to infinity and r to 0, and a sketch of V(r) rising to a maximum at sqrt(3) then falling.
)

however for part d) instead we have ##V(r) = ( \frac{J^2}{r^2}+1)(r-\frac{1}{r}) ## and now ##\lim r \to \infty = r ## but ##\lim r \to 0 = -1/r^3 ##. from this I can draw the start and end , but am unsure how to connect in the middle- curving upward or downward. compared to the above, null example, where the critical point is solvable and i can check stability to deduce the shape, here the critical point is unsolvable so I am unsure how to do this.

I have the following so far:

Handwritten sketch: V(r) = (J²/r² + 1)(r - 1/r), a graph of V against r with axes, a curve rising steeply to the right, and text noting V ~ r as r tends to infinity, r_max, and that the cubic cannot be solved.


the answer is:
Handwritten sketch of an effective potential V(r) = (J^2/r^2 + 1)(r - 1/r) on grid paper, with a curve rising from the lower left to the upper right and an annotation that V(r) ~ r as r tends to infinity; the r_max region is marked and the cubic equation is noted as unsolvable.

I AM UNSURE WHY, how to deduce the shape on the 'jointy' bit.

Many thanks in advance.

(I believe there may be an error in the solution since for a time-like geodesic instead of ##\epsilon=1 ## it should be ##\epsilon=-1## however I am interested in the principal of the graph sketching, so, assuming the graph sketch is consistent with the value of epsilon chosen for the solution, I'd like to ignore this please and focus on the graph sketching. Thanks).
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten working on grid paper: null geodesics case epsilon = 0 with V(r) = (J^2/r^2)(r - 1/r), limits as r to infinity and r to 0, and a sketch of V(r) rising to a maximum at sqrt(3) then falling.
    vr null.png
    65.9 KB · Views: 706
  • Handwritten sketch of an effective potential V(r) = (J^2/r^2 + 1)(r - 1/r) on grid paper, with a curve rising from the lower left to the upper right and an annotation that V(r) ~ r as r tends to infinity; the r_max region is marked and the cubic equation is noted as unsolvable.
    vr tl.png
    62.8 KB · Views: 778
  • Handwritten sketch: V(r) = (J²/r² + 1)(r - 1/r), a graph of V against r with axes, a curve rising steeply to the right, and text noting V ~ r as r tends to infinity, r_max, and that the cubic cannot be solved.
    vr me.png
    65.5 KB · Views: 619
  • Typeset problem statement: metric ds^2 = -(r - 1/r)dt^2 + (r - 1/r)^-1 dr^2 + r^2(dtheta^2 + sin^2 theta dphi^2), with parts (a) to (d) on Killing constants, geodesic potential, null orbits and timelike sketch.
    vrq.png
    30.4 KB · Views: 987
Last edited: