Help with finding the coefficient of kinetic friction

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around determining the coefficient of kinetic friction in a system involving two masses connected by a pulley. Participants explore the dynamics of forces acting on the masses and the relationships between tension and friction.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the use of free-body diagrams to analyze forces acting on the masses. There are attempts to derive equations for horizontal and vertical forces, and some participants suggest working with symbols instead of substituting numerical values early in the process.

Discussion Status

The discussion is active, with participants providing guidance on how to approach the problem. There is an exploration of the relationships between tension and friction, and participants are questioning the assumptions about the system, particularly regarding the equality of tensions in an ideal pulley system.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the system is assumed to be ideal, meaning the rope and pulley have no mass, which influences the tension relationships. There is also mention of the acceleration being zero, indicating a state of equilibrium in the system.

riseofphoenix
Messages
294
Reaction score
2
ScreenShot2012-12-11at104406AM.png


Ok so I tried making myself a free-body diagram but I reached a dead end..

Step 1) fkinetic = μkn
fkinetic = μk(251)
fkinetic / 251 = μk

Step 2)
Fx:
T1

Fy
n = (m)(g) = 251 N
120.5 N

Step 3)

ƩFx = m(-a) since it's moving the left or ƩFx = 0 (since it's moving at CONSTANT velocity)
ƩFy = ma

Step 4)

ƩFy: 251 + 120.5 = (25.58 + 12.28)a

*** I got the masses by solving 120.5 = m(9.81) and 251 = m(9.81) ***

ƩFy: 371.5 = (37.86)a
ƩFy: 371.5/37.86 = a
ƩFy: 9.81 = aStep 5)

T1 = m(-a)
T1 = (25.58)(-9.81) = 250.9 = 251 :(

Help?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
One thing I would advise you to do is not to substitute the numbers in until the end - it's better to work with symbols as long as possible.

Using your free-body diagrams, write out equations for the horizontal and vertical forces acting on W1 and the vertical forces acting on W2.
Then see how you can combine them to get a simple expression for μ
 
ap123 said:
One thing I would advise you to do is not to substitute the numbers in until the end - it's better to work with symbols as long as possible.

Using your free-body diagrams, write out equations for the horizontal and vertical forces acting on W1 and the vertical forces acting on W2.
Then see how you can combine them to get a simple expression for μ

W1

Forces in x direction
T1
fk

Forces in y direction
Fn
_________________________

W2

Forces in x direction
none

Forces in y direction
T2
_________________________

ƩFx: T1 + fk = ?
T1 + 251μk = ?​
ƩFy: Fn + T2 = ?
(m1g) + (-m2a) = ?​
(25.58*9.81) + (-12.28*9.81) = ?​
251 -120.5 = ?​
130.5 = ?​
What next?
 
Last edited:
ƩF = ma. In this case, you're told that a=0, and this applies to both masses.
Also, you need to remember the direction of the forces.
So,
ƩFx = T1 - fk = 0
→ T1 = fk

Similar problem with signs for the forces on W2
 
ap123 said:
ƩF = ma. In this case, you're told that a=0, and this applies to both masses.
Also, you need to remember the direction of the forces.
So,
ƩFx = T1 - fk = 0
→ T1 = fk

Similar problem with signs for the forces on W2

Ohh ok.
 
ap123 said:
ƩF = ma. In this case, you're told that a=0, and this applies to both masses.
Also, you need to remember the direction of the forces.
So,
ƩFx = T1 - fk = 0
→ T1 = fk

Similar problem with signs for the forces on W2

Ohh ok.ƩFx: T1 + (-fk) = ma
T1 - 251μk = m(0)​
T1 - 251μk = 0​
T1 = 251μk

Wait but I still have to find T1...How do I do that?

ƩFy: Fn + T2 = ?
(m1g) + (-m2a) = ?​
(25.58*9.81) + (-12.28*9.81) = ?​
251 - 120.5 = ?​
130.5 = ?​
 
Your first equation is ok.

Apply the same reasoning to the second equation:
ƩFy = T2 - W2 = 0
→ T2 = W2

Now, T1 = T2 since the pulley just changes the direction of the tension force and not its value.

So, you can combine the 2 equations to eliminate the tension force - the answer should be clear after doing that.
 
ap123 said:
Your first equation is ok.

Apply the same reasoning to the second equation:
ƩFy = T2 - W2 = 0
→ T2 = W2

Now, T1 = T2 since the pulley just changes the direction of the tension force and not its value.

So, you can combine the 2 equations to eliminate the tension force - the answer should be clear after doing that.

T1 = T2
T1 = 120.5

So for

T1 = 251μk
120.5 = 251μk
0.48 = μk

Thanks!

One quick question though...
Whenever I see a problem like this - two blocks and a pulley...

T1 always equals T2?
 
As long as the rope and pulley are 'ideal', ie don't have any mass, then the 2 tensions will be the same.
 
  • #10
ap123 said:
As long as the rope and pulley are 'ideal', ie don't have any mass, then the 2 tensions will be the same.

Ok thanks a bunch!
 

Similar threads

Replies
18
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
18K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K