How can a photon exists on its own without a mass?

In summary, thermal energy is carried by particles with mass, while light/photons are massless particles that carry energy and momentum through electromagnetic waves. Despite being referred to as particles in common language, photons are more accurately described as excitations of the electromagnetic field. Light can transfer heat through conduction and radiation, and the concept of wave-particle duality is primarily used for laymen understanding rather than in physics.
  • #1
mvbn
2
0
For example, thermal energy exists and has no mass, but is carried by particles which have mass. A photon is described as a particle - how can a photon exist on its own, travel in space and even push other particles with mass if it has no mass itself?I am not sure if that thread should be in quantum physics section or not so I post it here
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
mvbn said:
For example, thermal energy exists and has no mass, but is carried by particles which have mass.

radiated thermal energy is carried by infrared photons ( more precisely IR Electromagnetic radiation) massless particles <-- and I use that term broadly
 
  • #3
mvbn: Welcome to PF!
mvbn said:
For example, thermal energy exists and has no mass, but is carried by particles which have mass.
As davenn wrote, electomagnetic radiation is how I would consider thermal energy 'travels'. You may be speaking about kinetic energy when you mention particles that have mass, as in the collisions of molecules in a gas or their vibrations in a solid.
A photon is described as a particle
Photons are best thought of as the minimum amount (quanta) of light that can be transferred. You will read that light/photons exhibit a "wave/particle duality", but the experts will tell you this is an analogy, and it's better to think of photons as neither (they are their own unique, quantum object.)
how can a photon exist on its own, travel in space
Light travels as electromagnetic waves - an excitation of the EM field.

and even push other particles with mass if it has no mass itself?
Light has energy and momentum. The E=mc^2 equation from Einstein that most folks are familiar with explains the relationship between energy and mass. But there is more to the right hand side of the equation that's frequently omitted - a momentum component for massless particles. The equation reduces to the simpler E=mc^2 when the momentum term iz zero. So light does indeed exert a pressure, albeit ever so small, from the momentum it carries.
 
  • #4
davenn said:
radiated thermal energy is carried by infrared photons ( more precisely IR Electromagnetic radiation) massless particles <-- and I use that term broadly
I thought When One vibrating particle(atom) hits another vibrating particle and causes it to vibrate more that is transfer of thermal energy without photons. Am I wrong?.

@TumblingDice If photons are not particles I can't undestrand why it is teached that they are particles. Even wikipedia says "A photon is an elementary particle, the quantum of light and all other forms of electromagnetic radiation,". It says clearly that it is "elementary particle" and not just have particle properties. It is confusing that I don't know if I should think about it as particle or not.
 
  • #5
mvbn said:
I thought When One vibrating particle(atom) hits another vibrating particle and causes it to vibrate more that is transfer of thermal energy without photons. Am I wrong?.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_radiation

mvbn said:
It says clearly that it is "elementary particle" and not just have particle properties.
Light has particle properties. Photons are particles.
 
  • #6
mvbn said:
I thought When One vibrating particle(atom) hits another vibrating particle and causes it to vibrate more that is transfer of thermal energy without photons. Am I wrong?.
You are not wrong. This is an example of conduction. There are additional ways to transfer heat. One, as A.T. pointed out, is radiation.
 
  • #7
A.T. said:
Light has particle properties. Photons are particles.

bhobba said:
Well first a correct analysis with photons really needs QED (Quantum Electrodynamics) since the photons are actually excitations of an underlying EM field... ...if they were actually quantum particles in the usual sense, which is the usual way its treated in beginning treatments - its wrong - but we all must start somewhere.

ZapperZ said:
We still use the “duality” description of light when we try to describe light to laymen because wave and particle are behavior most people are familiar with. However, it doesn’t mean that in physics, or in the working of physicists, such a duality has any significance.
^ Excerpt from PF FAQ: "Is Light A Wave Or A Particle?"
https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/is-light-a-wave-or-a-particle.511178/
 

1. How can a photon exist without a mass?

According to the theory of relativity, mass and energy are equivalent and can be converted into each other. Photons are particles of energy, and therefore do not have a rest mass.

2. How can something without mass have momentum?

While photons do not have a rest mass, they do have a momentum due to their energy. The equation E=mc^2, where E is energy, m is mass, and c is the speed of light, shows that energy and mass are interchangeable. This means that photons with energy also have momentum.

3. How does the lack of mass affect the behavior of a photon?

The lack of mass allows photons to travel at the speed of light, which is the maximum speed in the universe. It also allows them to be unaffected by gravitational forces, as mass is what creates and interacts with gravity.

4. Can a photon exist in a vacuum without any other particles?

Yes, a photon can exist in a vacuum without any other particles. In fact, photons are often described as the carriers of electromagnetic radiation in a vacuum.

5. How does the lack of mass in a photon contribute to its wave-particle duality?

The wave-particle duality of a photon is a result of the uncertainty principle in quantum mechanics. The lack of mass in a photon allows it to behave as both a wave and a particle, depending on the observation or interaction with other particles.

Similar threads

Replies
19
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
19
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
27
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
851
Replies
13
Views
1K
Back
Top