How do I factor out negative signs in equations?

  • Thread starter Thread starter sobergeek23
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Factoring Negative
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around factoring out negative signs in algebraic expressions, specifically in the context of simplifying a fraction involving polynomials. Participants are examining the expression (3a+4b)(a-3b) over b(3a+4b) multiplied by 1 over b^2(3b-a)(3b+a) and the implications of negative factors in the simplification process.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants are attempting to understand how to factor out negative signs and how this affects the simplification of the given expression. Questions arise regarding the equivalence of (3b-a) and (-a+3b), and how factoring out a negative impacts the overall expression.

Discussion Status

There is ongoing confusion regarding the treatment of negative signs in the simplification process. Some participants are questioning the steps taken in the simplification, particularly the role of the factor of -1 and its effect on the denominator. Guidance has been offered regarding the use of small numbers to test the reasoning, but no consensus has been reached on the correct interpretation of the negative signs.

Contextual Notes

Participants express difficulty in using the forum's formatting tools for equations, which may hinder clear communication of their mathematical reasoning. There is also mention of a potential typo in the original problem setup, which adds to the confusion.

sobergeek23
Messages
20
Reaction score
1
Member warned that the homework template must be used
i have no idea how to use the punctuation marks for writing equations..ill do my best..

(3a+4b)(a-3b) over b(3a+4b) multiplied by 1 over b^2(3b-a)(3b+a)

during the cross cancelling the 3b-a would be multiplied by a negative one to switch the problem over right? (-1)(3b-a) in order to cross cancel with the (a-3b) in the top left..
the answer was 1 over b^3(a-3b) but i don't understand the whole negative sign thing..isnt (3b-a) the same as (-a+3b)? so factoring out the negative would make it (a-3b) and it cancels with the top left fraction but then i also have the (b) (b^2)(3b+a) on the bottom so how do they get b^3(a-3b)? i get the b^3 part ..i thought maybe the negative one i factored out in the (3b-a) would have also applied to the (3b+a) but then wouldn't it be (-3b-a) ..im so confussed on factoring out negatives..
 
Physics news on Phys.org
sobergeek23 said:
i have no idea how to use the punctuation marks for writing equations..ill do my best..

(3a+4b)(a-3b) over b(3a+4b) multiplied by 1 over b^2(3b-a)(3b+a)

during the cross cancelling the 3b-a would be multiplied by a negative one to switch the problem over right? (-1)(3b-a) in order to cross cancel with the (a-3b) in the top left..
the answer was 1 over b^3(a-3b)
Sure there isn't a typo? What happened to ##(3b+a)##?
but i don't understand the whole negative sign thing..isnt (3b-a) the same as (-a+3b)? so factoring out the negative would make it (a-3b) and it cancels with the top left fraction but then i also have the (b) (b^2)(3b+a) on the bottom so how do they get b^3(a-3b)?
see above
i get the b^3 part ..i thought maybe the negative one i factored out in the (3b-a) would have also applied to the (3b+a) but then wouldn't it be (-3b-a) ..im so confussed on factoring out negatives..
I don't really see where the ##-1## has gone to, neither in the quoted answer nor in the confusion of your reasoning.

To write formulas, you should read
https://www.physicsforums.com/help/latexhelp/

It's not that difficult but makes reading a lot easier. I think you have all you need to simplify the quotient. Just keep track of your parts. A simple trick to see, whether a step is write or wrong, is to plug in some small numbers for ##a## and ##b##, like ##\pm 1## or ##\pm 2##.
 
sobergeek23 said:
i have no idea how to use the punctuation marks for writing equations..ill do my best..

(3a+4b)(a-3b) over b(3a+4b) multiplied by 1 over b^2(3b-a)(3b+a)

during the cross cancelling the 3b-a would be multiplied by a negative one to switch the problem over right? (-1)(3b-a) in order to cross cancel with the (a-3b) in the top left..
the answer was 1 over b^3(a-3b) but i don't understand the whole negative sign thing..isnt (3b-a) the same as (-a+3b)? so factoring out the negative would make it (a-3b) and it cancels with the top left fraction but then i also have the (b) (b^2)(3b+a) on the bottom so how do they get b^3(a-3b)? i get the b^3 part ..i thought maybe the negative one i factored out in the (3b-a) would have also applied to the (3b+a) but then wouldn't it be (-3b-a) ..im so confussed on factoring out negatives..

Was it the problem?
\frac{(3a+4b)(a-3b)}{b(3a+4b)}\frac{1}{b^2(3b-a)(3b+a)}
=\frac{(3a+4b)(a-3b)}{b(3a+4b)}\frac{1}{-b^2(a-3b)(3b+a)}

You canceled out a-3b, and you got a (-1) factor in the denominator. Dividing by -1 makes the sign of the whole fraction negative, so it is
-\left(\frac{(3a+4b)}{b(3a+4b)}\frac{1}{b^2(3b+a)}\right)after further simplification, you get the desired formula.

The minus sign is the same as a factor of (-1).
Remember the rules when calculating with factors. \frac{a}{bc}=\frac{1}{b}\frac{a}{c}
If b = -1,
\frac{a}{-c}=\frac{1}{-1}\frac{a}{c}
and you know that \frac{1}{-1}= -1
so \frac{a}{-c}=-\frac{a}{c}
 
#3 ..writing it out not that hard? looking at that page just made my eyes cross and my brain short circuit..ugh forget it..
 
sobergeek23 said:
#3 ..writing it out not that hard? looking at that page just made my eyes cross and my brain short circuit..ugh forget it..

Can you write (3a+4b)(a-3b)/( b(3a+4b))? Is that easier than writing \frac{(3a+4b)(s-3b)}{b(3a+4)}? Basically, that's all there is to it!

When you write x = \frac{a}{b} in LaTeX, you get ##x = \frac{a}{b}## after you enclose everything between two # symbols, like this: # # your stuff # # (remove spaces between the two # signs at the start and the end). Using # delimiters produces an "in-line" formula. If you want a "displayed" formula/equation, like this
$$ x =\frac{a}{b},$$
you should replace the # symbols by $ signs, so write $ $ your stuff $ $ (with no spaces between the two $ signs at the start and the end).
 
Last edited:
no idea what that means...the first thing u wrote made sense, the rest way over my head..this site won't let me post pictures either otherwise id just upload a pic of the problem
 

Similar threads

Replies
21
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K