How does the capillary tube in refrigerators work?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the functioning of capillary tubes in refrigerators, specifically how they affect pressure and temperature of the refrigerant. Participants explore the mechanics of pressure drops, cooling effects, and the role of phase changes in refrigeration systems.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants inquire how a smaller diameter in a capillary tube contributes to a decrease in pressure and whether this leads to cooling of the liquid refrigerant.
  • Others discuss the capillary tube mat as a surface heat exchanger, emphasizing its efficiency in energy use and rapid temperature response.
  • One participant suggests that the cooling effect does not occur in the capillary tube itself but rather during the phase change in the evaporator.
  • Another participant mentions that the cooling effect is associated with the Joule-Thomson effect and questions the understanding of "cooling" in the context of refrigeration.
  • Some argue that the pressure drop in the capillary tube is due to friction and energy loss, while others emphasize the importance of the evaporator in the cooling process.
  • There is a discussion about the specifics of how much evaporation occurs in the expansion valve versus the evaporator and its implications for cooling efficiency.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on where the cooling effect occurs, with some asserting it happens in the evaporator while others argue it is related to the capillary tube. The discussion remains unresolved, with multiple competing perspectives on the mechanics involved.

Contextual Notes

Participants reference the Joule-Thomson effect and the thermodynamic processes involved in vapor-compression refrigeration, highlighting the complexity of the concepts discussed. There are also mentions of specific definitions and terminology related to cooling and thermal energy transfer that remain ambiguous.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be of interest to individuals studying refrigeration technology, thermodynamics, or those seeking to understand the principles behind capillary tubes in cooling systems.

Karagoz
How does the capillary tube decrease the pressure on the liquid when its diameter is smaller?

How small diameter of capillary tube is helpful in causing more pressure drop?

And how, when pressure drops, the liquid instantly cools down?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Do you mean capillary tube mat for cooling?
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capillary_tube_mat said:
A room whose temperature is controlled by the use of capillary tube mats as a surface heat-exchanger requires flow temperatures for heating or cooling which need only be a few degrees away from the desired room temperature. At the same time, due to the large number of parallel capillary tubes, the drive energy required to maintain the flow is comparatively low in relation to “single tube systems”, which are laid in the form of a meander (typical installation of underfloor heating pipes). Due to the small distance of the capillary tubes to the surface of the room area, the system reacts very quickly. The temperature of the heating or cooling medium is given off very evenly and quickly to the environment due to the large number of capillary tubes. These two properties – very good heat transmission and low pressure loss – provide an advantage in terms of energy saving. In the broad definition of the terms of the technology, the capillary tube mat is a surface heat exchanger, and can be used for the transfer of heat between two media.
 
Karagoz said:
How does the capillary tube decrease the pressure on the liquid when its diameter is smaller?
It's an obstruction, like a valve, so there is an energy loss associated with it. It is basically friction/drag.
How small diameter of capillary tube is helpful in causing more pressure drop?
Depends on the specifics of the scenario but in general the smaller the tube the larger the pressure drop.
And how, when pressure drops, the liquid instantly cools down?
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joule–Thomson_effect
 
Karagoz said:
How does the capillary tube decrease the pressure on the liquid when its diameter is smaller?

How small diameter of capillary tube is helpful in causing more pressure drop?

And how, when pressure drops, the liquid instantly cools down?
We want the pressure inside the evaporator to be quite low. To achieve that we do two things:
1: We make a small hole through which the (liquid) refrigerant leaks into the evaporator.
2: We attach a quite effective pump to the other end of the evaporator. The pump sucks (gaseous) refrigerant out of the evaporator.

Doesn't it make sense that those two things are the requirements for low pressure?

(The pump is the compressor)
 
So smaller diameter --> liquid touches more the tube --> higher friction --> more energy loss --> and more energy loss causes drop in pressure?
 
russ_watters said:

I disagree. The cooling effect does not occur in the capillary tube. It occurs there were the phase change occurs. The phase change occurs in the evaporator.
If the refrigerant cooled while going through the capillary tube, it lost heat energy:
mass * specific heat capacity * temperature change
That is a quite small number, not as large as heat of phase changes.
 
Last edited:
jartsa said:
I disagree. The cooling effect does not occur in the capillary tube. It occurs there were the phase change occurs. The phase change occurs in the evaporator.
Do you have access to a split system AC unit where you can identify the expansion valve? Touch the refrigerant line.

Evaporation(boiling) occurs at constant temperature.

Or maybe more to the point, in the evaporator you are cooling air by passing it over cold coils to transfer heat to the refrigerant. It has to already be cold to do that and it can't get colder by heating it!
If the refrigerant cooled while going through the capillary tube, it lost heat energy:
mass * specific heat capacity * temperature change
That is a quite small number, not as large as heat of phase changes.
I think you are missing the function of the capillary tube: It's to make the refrigerant lose pressure.
 
russ_watters said:
Do you have access to a split system AC unit where you can identify the expansion valve? Touch the refrigerant line.

Evaporation(boiling) occurs at constant temperature.

Or maybe more to the point, in the evaporator you are cooling air by passing it over cold coils to transfer heat to the refrigerant. It has to already be cold to do that and it can't get colder by heating it!
There are two fridge parts where refrigerant temperature drops: the expansion valve and those warm tubes at the back of the fridge.

The liquid that comes out of the expansion valve is cold because a small fraction of it has evaporated.

The liquid that is in the evaporator is cold, despite of it being warmed, because it is evaporating.

If 10% of evaporation occurs in the expansion valve and 90% of evaporation occurs in the evaporator, then the evaporator is the main part where cooling occurs. 'Cooling' does not mean drop of temperature here, it means staying cool, despite of being warmed.
 
  • #11
Sorry, @Karagoz, we made a bit of a mess of this and it started with me. Let me try to clean it up...
russ_watters said:
jartsa said:
I disagree.
Well, at least in part your disagreement is correct. I had the Joule-Thomson effect in my head due to a recent thread on air-only refrigeration and failed to switch gears. Here's the wiki on vapor compression refrigeration:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vapor-compression_refrigeration#Thermodynamic_analysis_of_the_system

The OP is primarily about step 4-5, which is described: as:
"Between points 4 and 5, the saturated liquid refrigerant passes through the expansion valve and undergoes an abrupt decrease of pressure. That process results in the adiabatic flash evaporation and auto-refrigeration of a portion of the liquid (typically, less than half of the liquid flashes). The adiabatic flash evaporation process is isenthalpic (occurs at constant enthalpy)."

To put it more simply, by reducing the pressure you reduce the boiling point to below its current temperature, which causes a temperature drop until the saturation temperature is reached, where liquid and gas can coexist.

However, I think you are still muddying the waters with confusing usage of the word "cooling" or "cooling effect":
The cooling effect does not occur in the capillary tube. It occurs there were the phase change occurs. [snip]

If the refrigerant cooled while going through the capillary tube, it lost heat energy:
mass * specific heat capacity * temperature change
That is a quite small number, not as large as heat of phase changes.
What does "cooling effect" mean? To me, the verb "cool" can mean both "to lose thermal energy" and "to make colder". Since those definitions do not overlap completely, some clarification is in order. So here is what happens in the capillary tube:
It gets colder (temperature drops) without losing thermal energy, but while doing a little bit of work. The vast majority of the temperature change though is kind of as you say, due to the phase change reducing sensible heat and increasing latent heat (boiling). So while one definition (getting colder) definitely applies, the other (releasing thermal energy) mostly doesn't. However:
The cooling effect does not occur in the capillary tube. It occurs there were the phase change occurs.[snip] The phase change occurs in the evaporator.
Since the refrigerant is neither losing thermal energy nor getting colder in the evaporator, I can't see how you can say it is "cooling" in the evaporator. Indeed, the only one of the two definitions that applies is applied backwards: the refrigerant is gaining thermal energy in the evaporator, which means it is being heated. Just like a boiling pot on a stove is at constant temperature while still being heated.
jartsa said:
There are two fridge parts where refrigerant temperature drops: the expansion valve and those warm tubes at the back of the fridge.

The liquid that comes out of the expansion valve is cold because a small fraction of it has evaporated.

The liquid that is in the evaporator is cold, despite of it being warmed, because it is evaporating.
Yes. And just to be clear, "the warm tubes at the back of the fridge" are the condenser coils.
If 10% of evaporation occurs in the expansion valve and 90% of evaporation occurs in the evaporator, then the evaporator is the main part where cooling occurs. 'Cooling' does not mean drop of temperature here, it means staying cool, despite of being warmed.
So it is being heated but it is cooling? I think you're just mixing up the to and from of the heat transfer: the evaporator coil is cooling the air while heating the refrigerant. Again: you would never use the word "cooling" to describe what is happening to a boiling pot of water on a stove.

[edit] Er, caveat due to a cumbersome system definition. You could say the water itself on a boiling pot on the stove is losing thermal energy to evaporation, which is "cooling" while simultaneously being heated by the stove, but that system definition isn't allowed in the refrigeration cycle because you aren't discarding the gaseous refrigerant as it boils.
jartsa said:
@Karagoz: Here's a good explanation of how refrigerators work:
http://mocomi.com/how-does-a-refrigerator-work/

Everybody: Anything wrong with that explanation?
Just a minor quibble: It oddly splits the condenser into two separate steps/devices. It's only one step/device (the coil).
 
  • #12
The English language is full of problems. The word "Heating" can be taken to mean 'increasing temperature' or 'supplying heat to' and a good explanation of refrigeration methods should make clear which meaning is involved each time the word 'heating' is used. I went to a wedding, many years ago, in a massive granite church on the Yorkshire Moors. It was the coldest place I have ever had to stand in. The caretaker insisted he had "had the heating on all morning". It had not heated it up (raised the temperature) at all as the place was full of holes!
We spend (waste) a lot of thread pages on PF arguing at cross purposes due to the different meanings of words. If you want to resolve a problem like this one then try to put things another way, avoiding the offending word. People will thank you.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
4K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
4K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 48 ·
2
Replies
48
Views
6K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K