How long does it take for a bleeding cut to stop when tightly compressed?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Evo
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Cut
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the duration it takes for a bleeding cut to stop when tightly compressed. Participants share personal experiences, suggest first aid techniques, and inquire about the specifics of the injury, including its depth and the materials available for bandaging. The conversation touches on practical advice and the need for medical attention in certain cases.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant notes that bleeding stops while pressure is applied but resumes immediately upon release.
  • Another mentions that their cuts typically stop bleeding after a couple of minutes of pressure.
  • Concerns are raised about the duration of bleeding, with one participant stating it has been an hour.
  • Several participants suggest the need for first aid supplies and inquire about the depth of the cut.
  • There are suggestions for improvised bandaging techniques, including using a big band-aid as a butterfly bandage.
  • Some participants discuss the importance of elevation and direct pressure to control bleeding.
  • One participant shares a personal experience of bleeding for several days after a deep cut.
  • There are inquiries about medications that might inhibit clotting, with one participant denying the use of blood thinners.
  • Multiple participants express concern about the severity of the injury and suggest seeking medical attention if bleeding continues.
  • Humor is used in the discussion, with light-hearted comments about the situation and the need for first aid supplies.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the importance of applying pressure and using bandaging techniques, but there is no consensus on the exact duration for bleeding to stop or the necessity of medical intervention, as some suggest it may be needed while others offer home remedies.

Contextual Notes

Participants express uncertainty about the effectiveness of their first aid measures and the adequacy of their supplies. The discussion highlights the variability in individual responses to injuries and the need for personalized assessment of the situation.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for individuals interested in first aid practices, those seeking advice on managing minor injuries, or anyone curious about the variability in healing and bleeding times for cuts.

Evo
Staff Emeritus
Messages
24,114
Reaction score
3,277
How long should it take to stop bleeding after you have it tightly compressed? It's not bleeding as long as I keep it closed and keep pressure on it, but the second I remove the pressure, it bleeds like crazy.

This is me.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VxIBk1a3qdQ&feature=related
 
Last edited:
Biology news on Phys.org
Then keep the pressure on it...
 
But generally mine stops bleeding after a couple of minutes with pressure on it, then I put a band-aid on it for good measure.
 
It's been an hour.
 
Not good, better get first aid, Evo
 
I would definitely go and grab the first aid kit. Out of curiosity, just how deep did you cut it that it has been bleeding for an hour? Because if you cut it completely off, I'd definitely advise a bit more than just first aid...:P
 
It's not a long cut, but it's deep, so if I had one of those butterfly things they use instead of stitches, that would work. I need to stock up on first aid supplies. If I had one of those and a rubber finger, I think it would be ok.

If the car I am driving wasn't a stick, I might go to the drug store, but of course it's my right hand.

The Evo Child used up all of my bandages last time she was here because her new shoes were rubbing her feet.
 
What is it with the PF all of a sudden. Between you Evo and the golden retriever in the Medical Sciences forum, there's been a lot of bleeding going on this afternoon.

Are you taking any meds (OTC or prescription) that inhibit clotting? Are you on the baby-aspirin-a-day regimen? (If any of these questions are too personal for the open forum, PM me).

How deep and long is the cut? How did you wash it out? What bandaging materials do you have on hand?

If you washed it out well, and can seal it and bandage it shut, I'd leave it like that overnight. It might require stitches, though.
 
berkeman said:
What is it with the PF all of a sudden. Between you Evo and the golden retriever in the Medical Sciences forum, there's been a lot of bleeding going on this afternoon.

Are you taking any meds (OTC or prescription) that inhibit clotting? Are you on the baby-aspirin-a-day regimen? (If any of these questions are too personal for the open forum, PM me).

How deep and long is the cut? How did you wash it out? What bandaging materials do you have on hand?

If you washed it out well, and can seal it and bandage it shut, I'd leave it like that overnight. It might require stitches, though.
I just saw the dog tongue cut, poor thing.

Funny you should mention it Berkeman, I'vd had a lot of blood work' done recently and evey time they take blood, when they stop, they ask me if I am on blood thinners because I keep bleeding. I'm not on any that I know of and no aspirin.

I'm using a paper towel.
 
  • #10
Okay, so I see the issue may be not enough bandaging stuff to make a good seal. Maybe knock on some neighbor doors? If you knocked on mine, I have plenty of EMT stuff handy...
 
  • #11
berkeman said:
Okay, so I see the issue may be not enough bandaging stuff to make a good seal. Maybe knock on some neighbor doors? If you knocked on mine, I have plenty of EMT stuff handy...
Yep, I'm out of everything.
 
  • #12
Maybe try this as an improvised butterfly. Take a big bandaid (you do have that at least, I hope), and cut off one side of the tape (leaving behind the center bandage and the other side of tape. Use that tape piece as a butterfly, applying it directly over the cut. Then apply other bandages and dressing around that. The tape should keep the cut closed. Use direct pressure and elevation, and stay that way for an hour (sorry). After that you should be sealed up enough to last until you can get better dressings. I wouldn't remove the original one for a day or two, if that's practical. And be gentle when you do remove it, pulling from the edge nearest one end of the cut, and pulling the tape off parallel to the cut.
 
  • #13
Evo said:
Yep, I'm out of everything.

Well, you're going to need *something*! Can you call somebody to bring you some stuff, or else the neighbor knock thing?

EDIT -- Looks like the golden retriever is okay now.
 
  • #14
Oh, I found the little portable first aid kit that I bought the Evo Child for her purse. It has a couple of bandaids in it. I'll keep holding the paper towel on it for awhile longer then try a bandaid.

Nice to have an online EMT here. :-)
 
  • #15
Evo said:
Nice to have an online EMT here. :-)

Expanding to doggie EMT, apparently :smile:
 
  • #16
Stop trying to kill yourself.
 
  • #17
Kurdt said:
Stop trying to kill yourself.
:smile: Well the first bandaid attempt failed miserably, soaked through with blood. Paper towel has been re-applied.
 
  • #18
berkeman said:
Expanding to doggie EMT, apparently :smile:
I'm impressed with your doggie skills. Lucky I live almost within walking distance of an after hours animal emergency room. I've spent thousands of dollars there rescuing stray animals.
 
  • #19
Depends on how bad you cut it, Evo - when I put that drill through my thumb, it bled continuously for a few days (when not tightly wrapped), then off and on for the rest of the week.
 
  • #20
Evo said:
:smile: Well the first bandaid attempt failed miserably, soaked through with blood. Paper towel has been re-applied.

I'm assuming that you've been elevating well this whole time (right?). Have you had some first aid instruction where pressure points were covered? Although, you pretty much need a 2nd person to be able to do direct pressure and the brachial pressure point at the same time. Plus you need to know how and when to moderate the pressure point, so that you don't starve the rest of your arm too much while the thumb wound clots.

Try this -- wrap your fingers around the base of your thumb and squeeze a bit to slow the flow of blood into the thumb, at the same time you squeeze the cut closed with your thumb and forefinger. Keep that elevated for 10 minutes, then ease off just a bit on the pressure and wait another 10 minutes, then see if you can close off the cut with the piece of tape I described cutting from a bandaid. Then apply another bandage over it, and dress with tape. Keep it elevated as best as you can.
 
  • #21
I have to bail for the night, Evo. If it doesn't clot up in the next hour or so, you should at least call a friend with some first aid experience who can bring over more bandages and dressing material. Or head to the ER for a couple of stitches and some clot-magic stuff.
 
  • #22
Good thing this didn't happen during the PF upgrade.
 
  • #23
Have you tried duct tape yet? That'll hold together anything. But if it's deep enough that it's still bleeding profusely enough to soak through band-aids or paper towels after an hour or two, it's probably time to find an ER or urgent care place that can toss in a couple stitches. A little bleeding if you mess with it would be normal, but to have it covered and still bleeding enough to soak through dressings sounds like it needs some medical attention.

(And for the record, when I first saw the thread title and Evo as the thread starter, for a moment I thought it read, "After you cut OFF your thumb." :rolleyes:
 
  • #24
berkeman said:
I'm assuming that you've been elevating well this whole time (right?). Have you had some first aid instruction where pressure points were covered? Although, you pretty much need a 2nd person to be able to do direct pressure and the brachial pressure point at the same time. Plus you need to know how and when to moderate the pressure point, so that you don't starve the rest of your arm too much while the thumb wound clots.another bandage over it, and dress with tape. Keep it elevated as best as you can.
:cry:

Moonbear said:
Have you tried duct tape yet? That'll hold together anything. But if it's deep enough that it's still bleeding profusely enough to soak through band-aids or paper towels after an hour or two, it's probably time to find an ER or urgent care place that can toss in a couple stitches. A little bleeding if you mess with it would be normal, but to have it covered and still bleeding enough to soak through dressings sounds like it needs some medical attention.

(And for the record, when I first saw the thread title and Evo as the thread starter, for a moment I thought it read, "After you cut OFF your thumb." :rolleyes:
I have no duct tape. :frown:

I may have to concede defeat on this one, although my cheapskate employer changed medical plans and what was a $40 ER copay is now a $125 copay.

MB, have you seen Greg's announcement that he's doing a MAJOR upgrade tomorrow or Tuesday? I mean MAJOR.

RUT RO, the BIG storm is hitting, I'm SOL now.
 
  • #25
Evo, go get it looked at by a professional. If it hasn't quit bleeding on its own with pressure and whatnot by now, it probably needs stitches. Get help. 'kay? :smile:
 
  • #26
My squash plants just got squashed. :cry:

I do believe this will need stitches. CRUD.

And my squash! :cry:
 
  • #27
Evo said:
My squash plants just got squashed. :cry:

I do believe this will need stitches. CRUD.

And my squash! :cry:

What squashed your squash?

Sorry to hear you may need stitches! If you still think you might be able to get by with just first aid but you're out of bandages, don't hesitate to call the fire department / medics. You've already paid for them through your taxes, and they're very qualified to bandage a cut - and of course they will recognize if you need stitches.

Besides, sometimes they're cute :!) .
 
  • #28
If you have any kind of tape, e.g. Scotch tape, that should work. I sliced my left thumb open on some sheet metal one time. I just wrapped it firmly, and kept it elevated. I don't think I went to the emergency room. I did put some ice on it.

If the blood is not clotting, the perhaps one is low on vitamin-K.
http://lpi.oregonstate.edu/infocenter/vitamins/vitaminK/
 
  • #29
lisab said:
What squashed your squash?
I'm too upset to even talk about it. :cry: I will assess the damage tomorrow. I was in such a hurry to get them inside away from the winds and hail and with blood running down my arm, I failed to make sure they were steady. :cry:

I have managed to finally stop the bleeding. I have a bandaid wrapped tightly enough around my thumb to stop it.

But my squash plants...:cry:
 
  • #30
Any history of hemophilia in the family?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
12K
  • · Replies 77 ·
3
Replies
77
Views
10K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
6K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
6K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
3K