How to ensure maximum possible joint torque for an actuator?

2 replies · 1K views · last reply
TheShermanTanker
Messages
13
Reaction score
4
Below, I have a joint system that consists of a fixed anchor and a moving arm:
Hand-drawn sketch of a joint: a moving arm extends left from a circled pivot marked O, and a vertical fixed anchor rises above the pivot. Labels read Moving arm, Fixed Anchor and Pivot.


What I want is simple: To attach a linear actuator on the moving arm in such a way that the mechanical advantage of the actuator is exactly 1 (Ie the actuator only has to generate exactly the amount of force as the load on the moving arm)

This may seem simple at first glance, just attach the actuator at the far end of the moving arm, right?

But there is a necessary constraint: The other end of the actuator has to be fixed to the fixed arm AND has to be as close to the moving arm as possible, I can't just stick the other end to anywhere I want. So now I end up with this:
Hand-drawn sketch of a joint: a horizontal arm pivoting at its right end, with a block labelled Actuator drawn above it and an arrow from the label pointing at the arm; a curved arrow labelled Load points to the left end of the arm.

The problem is that torque generated depends on perpendicular distance to the pivot. So no matter how far out I fix the actuator, it's still at a mechanical disadvantage, since the actual perpendicular distance to the pivot is very small

Anyone know how I can fix this issue?
 
Why not just fix the actuator to the moving arm? It just needs to push the load straight away from the end of the moving arm, right? Why does this force need to be transferred to the fixed arm through anything but the pivot bearing?

I guess I'm not understanding your problem statement so far...
 
TheShermanTanker said:
But there is a necessary constraint: The other end of the actuator has to be fixed to the fixed arm AND has to be as close to the moving arm as possible,
That's not a constraint, but an optimization goal.

TheShermanTanker said:
I can't just stick the other end to anywhere I want.
That's an ill-defined constraint.

TheShermanTanker said:
(Ie the actuator only has to generate exactly the amount of force as the load on the moving arm)
That's a constraint.
 
Last edited: