I am leaving, thanks for the great experience

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The thread revolves around a member's decision to leave the forum, expressing feelings of inadequacy and a desire to say goodbye. Participants reflect on personal struggles, share their thoughts on the member's contributions, and discuss the emotional aspects of leaving the community.

Discussion Character

  • Emotional support
  • Personal reflection
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Abigale expresses feelings of inadequacy and announces her decision to leave the forum, citing a belief that she "sucks."
  • Some participants encourage her not to be so hard on herself and question why she feels this way.
  • Others express sadness at her potential departure, emphasizing her popularity and positive contributions to the community.
  • Warren humorously reveals he is not actually 25, adding to the theme of identity and honesty in the discussion.
  • Gale shares similar feelings of inadequacy and reflects on the desire to learn and grow, while also contemplating leaving the forum.
  • Participants suggest that feelings of inadequacy are common and encourage continued engagement with the community for support.
  • Some members propose that quitting the forum will not resolve personal issues and encourage staying connected for help.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally express concern for Abigale and Gale, with many encouraging them to stay. However, there is no consensus on the feelings of inadequacy, as some members challenge the notion that they "suck" and emphasize their value in the community.

Contextual Notes

The discussion reflects personal struggles and emotional states, with participants sharing their own experiences and feelings of inadequacy. There are varying interpretations of what it means to feel "lost" or "messed up," and the conversation includes humor and light-heartedness amidst serious topics.

Who May Find This Useful

Members of online communities dealing with feelings of inadequacy, identity issues, or those seeking emotional support may find this discussion relatable and insightful.

  • #61
Originally posted by Monique
Well, believe me: I am a perfectionist and completely opposite from my sister who doesn't care about things. Being a perfectionist doesn't mean you have to be self critical. I look at a thing and think: "whoa, that's good, but I can improve it and then it would look even better!"

Yeah, I agree with Monique. Being self-critical is more focusing on and dwelling on your own shortcomings. While perfectionism is all around "..this isn't good enough yet.." It is often with rigorous rejection of his or her work. The difference is basically that being self-critical is an analyzation of how you can be better and perfectionalism is their work has to be just right by obsession.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #62
Just to sum up Guns N' Roses style, why let one bad apple spoil the whole damn bunch? So you think you suck at physics? so? a lot of people here do and that's why we (yes, i count as a lot of people...what an ego!) are on here, to learn and I am quite amazed that i do. This place is great because you arent judged and people are willing to answer the most INANE questions lol.

On another note, MONIQUE THAT IS SO COOL!...actually, where's the union jack? that has now delved into the realms of anti-cool cos there is no union jack...which brings me to another point Gale, you can't please everyone, but when it is yourself, you can get a more positive response from people. We wouldn't be trying to convince you to stay if we didnt like you!

it doesn't matter what age you are, I'm a 5 year old child protege with tentacles instead of arms (VERY hard to type) and i have been posing as an 18 year old but no-one is going to think different of me...except about the tentacles. :smile:
 
Last edited:
  • #63
personally i give that speech and 8.6
 
  • #64
Originally posted by jimmy p
On another note, MONIQUE THAT IS SO COOL!...actually, where's the union jack? that has now delved into the realms of anti-cool cos there is no union jack...which brings me to another point Gale, you can't please everyone, but when it is yourself, you can get a more positive response from people. We wouldn't be trying to convince you to stay if we didnt like you!:smile:
You were looking for the union jack? http://www.click-smilies.de/sammlung0903/travesmilies/flaggen1/smilie_flagge3.gif
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #65
Originally posted by Jeebus
Yeah, I agree with Monique. Being self-critical is more focusing on and dwelling on your own shortcomings. While perfectionism is all around "..this isn't good enough yet.." It is often with rigorous rejection of his or her work. The difference is basically that being self-critical is an analyzation of how you can be better and perfectionalism is their work has to be just right by obsession.

Know thyself. Knowing the world starts with knowing yourself, right? Shouldn't it be the same with perfecting the world? I think an obsession starts when you think maybe the circle is not round enough or something. But how can you not feel bad when you're not satisfied with yourself? If you have any trace of egocentrism in you you will. You can "survive" other things not being "perfect", but yourself?
 
  • #66
Originally posted by Sonty
But how can you not feel bad when you're not satisfied with yourself? If you have any trace of egocentrism in you you will. You can "survive" other things not being "perfect", but yourself?
Its shows to me an unbalanced situation, which is pulled out of proportion. I mean, egocentrism is not really healthy and a rather asocial behaviour.

Does something perfect exist? In real life not really. It is all about balancing things, you work until your feeling of satisfaction reaches a certain level. A perfectionist sets a bar higher than the average person and will work longer on a certain project and pay more attention to details.

I once new a person whose perception of life was based on perfectionalism, which is where I get my statement from: egocentrism is not really healthy and a rather asocial behaviour.

I tried convincing the person of the extend of perfectionalism and the harm it was doing, which only led to a lot of hoopla where the point had to be proven to me, that perfectionalism is in fact the best thing in the world and that it leads to a perfect life.

Well, I didn't have to prove anything for myself, the observation was clear enough.
 
  • #67
Originally posted by Monique
You were looking for the union jack? http://www.click-smilies.de/sammlung0903/travesmilies/flaggen1/smilie_flagge3.gif

These smilies are just...wicked http://www.click-smilies.de/sammlung0903/teufel/devil-smiley-009.gif


...btw, just watch the smilie for a while.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #68
those smileys are cool, i want them.

lookie lookie, at this moment, i am one post away from 100!
 
  • #69
Originally posted by Monique
Does something perfect exist? In real life not really. It is all about balancing things, you work until your feeling of satisfaction reaches a certain level. A perfectionist sets a bar higher than the average person and will work longer on a certain project and pay more attention to details.

maybe trying to find the "perfect" balance?
what if the project in question is "ME"?


I once new a person whose perception of life was based on perfectionalism, which is where I get my statement from: egocentrism is not really healthy and a rather asocial behaviour.

I tried convincing the person of the extend of perfectionalism and the harm it was doing, which only led to a lot of hoopla where the point had to be proven to me, that perfectionalism is in fact the best thing in the world and that it leads to a perfect life.

Well of course it doesn't lead to a perfect life. It doesn't even lead to a happy life. At least not under "normal" standards.
Ignorance is bliss...
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 42 ·
2
Replies
42
Views
4K