I can not calculate these Newton equations

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving a block and a car connected by a wire, focusing on calculating the acceleration of the car and the tension in the wire after the system is released. The subject area pertains to Newton's laws of motion and forces acting on inclined planes.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the equations of motion for both the car and the block, questioning the correctness of the original poster's notation and approach. Some suggest analyzing forces in the x and y directions separately, while others raise concerns about the choice of axes and components involved.

Discussion Status

The conversation is ongoing, with various interpretations of the problem being explored. Some participants provide guidance on how to set up the equations, while others seek clarification on the assumptions made regarding the forces acting on the system.

Contextual Notes

There is mention of the need to consider the incline's angle and the relationship between the accelerations of the car and the block. Participants are also addressing potential misunderstandings regarding the components of forces and the setup of free body diagrams.

Apprentice123
Messages
92
Reaction score
0
A block B of 20 kg is trapped by a wire of 2 m a car A of 30 kg. Determine (a) the acceleration of the car (b) the tension of the wire, immediately after the system was abandoned the rest, in the position shown in the figure. Despise is the friction.

Answer:
(a) 6,17 m/s^2
(b) 144 N

My attempt
CAR

ZFx = mA . a
Tcos(65) = 30a

Block B
ZFx = mB . a
Tsin(65) = mB.a

I can not calculate these equations
 

Attachments

  • 12.32.GIF
    12.32.GIF
    10.7 KB · Views: 522
Physics news on Phys.org


Apprentice123 said:
A block B of 20 kg is trapped by a wire of 2 m a car A of 30 kg. Determine (a) the acceleration of the car (b) the tension of the wire, immediately after the system was abandoned the rest, in the position shown in the figure. Despise is the friction.

Answer:
(a) 6,17 m/s^2
(b) 144 N

My attempt
CAR

ZFx = mA . a
Tcos(65) = 30a

Block B
ZFx = mB . a
Tsin(65) = mB.a

I can not calculate these equations


The equations are correct?
 


why are you writing ZFx? do you mean the x component of F? but the car moves in a direction where it has x and y components of the force [Fx and Fy]
for the tension of the wire there’s no Fx
 


drizzle said:
why are you writing ZFx? do you mean the x component of F? but the car moves in a direction where it has x and y components of the force [Fx and Fy]
for the tension of the wire there’s no Fx

ZF => Sum of forces
 


It is probably best to choose the x-axis as the axis parallel to the incline, both when looking at the forces on block A and the forces on Block B. If you look at block B first and sum forces in the "x" direction, that is, in the direction parallel to the incline, then it's Tsin25[/color] plus the weight force component =20a, where 'a' is the acceleration in that x direction parallel to the incline. Then look at Block A using the same set of axes, and don't forget to include the weight (gravity) force acting down the incline.
 


PhanthomJay said:
It is probably best to choose the x-axis as the axis parallel to the incline, both when looking at the forces on block A and the forces on Block B. If you look at block B first and sum forces in the "x" direction, that is, in the direction parallel to the incline, then it's Tsin25[/color] plus the weight force component =20a, where 'a' is the acceleration in that x direction parallel to the incline. Then look at Block A using the same set of axes, and don't forget to include the weight (gravity) force acting down the incline.

Not Tcos (25) ?
The acceleration of the block is the same car ?
 


Sorry, I may have misread this problem. I believe the problem is asking for the car acceleration and the tension in the wire holding the 20 kg mass (Block B) at the instant the car is released from rest, while the wire is in the vertical position. If that is the case, it seems you should look at block B and sum forces in the vertical y direction to get 20g - T = 20a_y. Then look at the car, and sum forces along the incline ( the weight and tension components acting along the incline as the assumed x direction) equal to 30a_x, where a_x and a_y are related by a_x =a_y/sin25.
 


PhanthomJay said:
Sorry, I may have misread this problem. I believe the problem is asking for the car acceleration and the tension in the wire holding the 20 kg mass (Block B) at the instant the car is released from rest, while the wire is in the vertical position. If that is the case, it seems you should look at block B and sum forces in the vertical y direction to get 20g - T = 20a_y. Then look at the car, and sum forces along the incline ( the weight and tension components acting along the incline as the assumed x direction) equal to 30a_x, where a_x and a_y are related by a_x =a_y/sin25.

How to calculate sum of forces in the X axis? Only has the weight
 


Apprentice123 said:
How to calculate sum of forces in the X axis? Only has the weight
For block B, I took the y-axis as vertical and the x-axis as horizontal, and summed forces in the y direction. But for the free body diagram of car A, I chose the x-axis to be the axis parallel to the incline, that is, 25 degrees up from the horizontal. So acting along the x-axis , you have the component of the cars weight (mgsin 25) and also the component of the Tension force (Tsin25). Their sum is 30a_x. You will need to solve 2 equations with 2 unknowns, noting first the relation beteen a_x and a_y (since the block and car are connected, they must accelerate at the same rate).
 
  • #10


PhanthomJay said:
For block B, I took the y-axis as vertical and the x-axis as horizontal, and summed forces in the y direction. But for the free body diagram of car A, I chose the x-axis to be the axis parallel to the incline, that is, 25 degrees up from the horizontal. So acting along the x-axis , you have the component of the cars weight (mgsin 25) and also the component of the Tension force (Tsin25). Their sum is 30a_x. You will need to solve 2 equations with 2 unknowns, noting first the relation beteen a_x and a_y (since the block and car are connected, they must accelerate at the same rate).

Thanks
 
  • #11


Clarificaton Edit: For block B, I took the y-axis as vertical and the x-axis as horizontal, and summed forces in the y direction. But for the free body diagram of car A, I chose the x-axis to be the axis parallel to the incline, that is, 25 degrees up from the horizontal. So acting along the inclined x-axis , you have the component of the cars weight (mgsin 25) and also the component of the Tension force (Tsin25). Their sum is 30a_x. You will need to solve 2 equations with 2 unknowns, noting first the relation beteen a_x and a_y (since the block and car are connected, they must initially vertically accelerate at the same rate a_y, but not so horizontally...until ultimately after a very brief time, once the lower block swings into its final position with the rope perpendicular to the incline, they accelerate together in both the x and y directions, at the same rate, but different from the initial value of the calcualted accelerataion.
 

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
7K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
5K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
5K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K