Increasing Torque, Force, and Work: Increasing crank Length (L)

[Femme37706]

Homework Statement

You are pulling water with a constant velocity from a well using a crank of length L. If the length of the crank was doubled, you could ...

Homework Equations

Work = Torque*angular distance
Torque = I*angular acceleration
Torque=F*d*sin(angle)
It looks like the force is being applied to the lever at 90 degrees

The Attempt at a Solution

The answer is "pull up double the amount of water with the same force", however I can't work out why this is the correct answer.

Maybe working backwards...
Double the amount of water has double the weight, (force of gravity)
So The torque from the crank wheel would then need to be double (?)
Torque = F*D*sin(90 degrees)
And if D is us doubled, then the same force does twice the Torque.
Is this right?

Also, I couldn't convince myself why these other options were wrong:
Incorrect: pull up the pail with half the number of revolutions
Incorrect: exert double the torque while pulling up the pail with half the work
Incorrect: exert four times the torque while pulling up the pail with the same work
Incorrect: pull up double the amount of water with the same work
Incorrect: pull up the pail with half the work and half the force

Thanks!

 

[tiny-tim]

Welcome to PF!

Hi Femme37706! Welcome to PF!

Hint: how much https://www.physicsforums.com/library.php?do=view_item&itemid=175" does the water exert on the shaft?

 

[Femme37706]

Oh, sorry, I should have been more clear. The "crank" is a circular pulley sort of crank that winds up a rope with a bucket attached to the end.
Does this affect your answer?

 

[tiny-tim]

It still has a shaft (that the rope winds round before going down the well).

 

[rwisz]

Increasing the length of the crank will indeed allow for more water to be pulled up with the same force. This is due to the relationship between torque, force, and distance. Doubling the crank length will double the distance from the center of rotation to the point where the force is applied, resulting in a doubling of the torque. This increased torque allows for more force to be applied to the water, resulting in a greater amount of water being pulled up with the same amount of work.

To understand why the other options are incorrect, it is important to consider the equations for torque and work. Torque is directly proportional to both force and distance, meaning that increasing the force or distance will result in an increase in torque. Work, on the other hand, is directly proportional to force and distance, but also takes into account the angle at which the force is applied. In this scenario, the force is being applied at a 90 degree angle, resulting in a simplified equation of work = force * distance. Doubling the distance will double the work, but doubling the force will result in a quadrupling of the work. Therefore, the incorrect options either do not take into account the effect of distance on torque, or they do not take into account the effect of angle on work.