Indian Colleges offering B.Sc Physics (H)

  • Context: Schools 
  • Thread starter Thread starter ManishR
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Physics
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the options for pursuing a B.Sc. in Physics (Hons) in India, particularly focusing on colleges that offer admission through entrance tests. Participants share their experiences, suggest institutions, and express concerns about the competitiveness and quality of various colleges.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • One participant inquires about colleges in India for B.Sc. Physics (Hons) and mentions interest in theoretical and mathematical physics.
  • Another participant lists several colleges, including Presidency College and Delhi University (DU), while expressing skepticism about the OP's chances of admission based on their marks.
  • Concerns are raised about the academic environment at DU, with suggestions that it is more focused on student culture than rigorous academics.
  • Some participants suggest considering IITs and IISERs, which offer integrated courses, as viable alternatives for pursuing physics.
  • There is a discussion about the trend of students from engineering backgrounds pursuing Ph.D.s in physics, with some participants challenging the generalization that most Ph.D. candidates come from engineering.
  • Another participant shares their personal experience of transitioning from a non-IIT university to IIT for post-graduate studies, highlighting the differences in academic environments.
  • A participant expresses a desire to pursue astrophysics but feels pressured to choose engineering due to limited opportunities in physics.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the quality and competitiveness of various colleges, particularly DU. There is no consensus on the best path forward for the OP, with multiple competing perspectives on the value of pursuing engineering versus physics.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention limitations in opportunities for pure science in India and the impact of parental pressure on educational choices. There are also unresolved concerns regarding the admission processes and the academic rigor of suggested institutions.

  • #31
@Schrudo

thanks for replying, would look forward to reading your write-up :D

Other than CMI, all the places that you have mentioned have 5yr Integrated M.Sc (other than TIFR and HRI which are PG only ...) so what would be the best places to apply for a simple 3yr B.Sc Physics ??

Also, I mentioned European Uni for Mohsen, Germany, Switzerland, Sweden, Norway and some others, not sure which don't charge any tution fees, so he could try for that...

samad
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
Regarding doing UG abroad: First and foremost, outside the US, I know of no place that gives scholarships etc. for undergrad students to study there

Look into the University of Alberta, in Edmonton,Alberta,Canada.

http://www.gradstudies.uAlberta.ca/intl/intlfund.htm
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #33
So it's almost time now that I decide my future. Am appearing for my 12th boards, and also preparing for AIEEE due in May. I am interested in pursuing a career in astrophysics. Got 89% in 10th if that even matters. Now, I am really confused whether I should take up engineering like others and sacrifice my dream, or do I pursue a degree in physics? Advice would be much appreciated.
Thanks
 
  • #34
How did your board practicals go ? I think if you get into some "awesome" engg. uni then it'd be better to just do engg. and later move into astrophyiscs.. otherwise just do B.Sc physics for some place good (there doesn't seem to be that many "good" physics places let alone "awesome" ones :P )

you could apply to UK or sumwhere else if you can convince your parents.. ?? that'd be the best option imo

good luck
Samad (in a very similar situtation.. )
 
  • #35
How did your board practicals go ? I think if you get into some "awesome" engg. uni then it'd be better to just do engg. and later move into astrophyiscs.. otherwise just do B.Sc physics for some place good (there doesn't seem to be that many "good" physics places let alone "awesome" ones :P )

you could apply to UK or sumwhere else if you can convince your parents.. ?? that'd be the best option imo

good luck
Samad (in a very similar situtation.. )
 
  • #36
Board practs were awesome. Although my performance on CET and AIEEE will decide my future!
 
  • #37
Sourabh N said:
I have studied there, so I can say, it was a good experience. As last post shows, some people had not-so-good experiences, but there are some who have great opinions. On average, for B.Sc. in Physics, I'd say it's one of the best (if not THE best) place in India.



Again, it depends. During my course, we did Introduction to quantum theory by the end of third year, which I think is NOT a regular part of a average International University. CMI and IMSc are like sister institutes and one can also do (and people do) graduate courses at IMSc during their undergraduate at CMI.
As far as self study goes, it's expected from you. If you join CMI, it is understood that you love physics and will study physics without some assignment/deadline to push you (though there are some courses with lots of assignments+deadlines, but I'm talking in general).



In most of the courses I attended, we could raise hand, address the professor by their first name, and ask question in the middle of the class, fearlessly.

Hi, could you tell me whether BSc Mathematics & Computer Science students are allowed to take (or have taken) graduate or MSc courses at CMI?
 
  • #39
doodle_sack said:
Hi, could you tell me whether BSc Mathematics & Computer Science students are allowed to take (or have taken) graduate or MSc courses at CMI?

Yes to both. One can also take courses offered at IMSc, given your schedule doesn't clash with courses at CMI (usually not an issue).
 
  • #41
Sourabh N said:
Yes to both. One can also take courses offered at IMSc, given your schedule doesn't clash with courses at CMI (usually not an issue).

Thanks. Could you tell me how many graduate level courses one is allowed to take? Or is there any restrictions in that case?
 
  • #42
doodle_sack said:
Thanks. Could you tell me how many graduate level courses one is allowed to take? Or is there any restrictions in that case?
That's rather specific. You should email the graduate coordinator (you can find the person on the website, somewhere) and clarify with them. Though usually, students take maximum 4-5 courses (with exceptions) and maybe 1-2 graduate courses max, in one semester (again, with exceptions).
 
  • #43
doodle_sack said:
Thanks. Could you tell me how many graduate level courses one is allowed to take? Or is there any restrictions in that case?
Thing about CMI is, there are very few administrative restrictions on any such issues. You can take as many electives (graduate level/at CMI or IMSc) as you can fit into your timetable (I think under new rules you have to convince your advisor that you won't flunk them).

Realistically, it is possible to take ~4-5 additional courses over 3 yrs (I took 5, although I've heard of a person who managed to do 9). Also, there's no restriction on physics students doing math courses and vice-versa.
 
  • #44
Thanks.
 
  • #45
Where could i get earlieer years CMI entrance test coz the sample papers on their site had Q's harder than those in from JEE ! lol :P
 
  • #46
I don't think they exist anywhere on the net. Most probably they (aka They should) have a different 'pattern' every time.
 
  • #47
Why should they have a diferent pattern every year?? Its annoying enuff understanding the JEE and AIEEE patterns let alone having to work differnetly for every college ..

could you please have a look at the sample paper and let me knw if the exam you gave had that hard Q's ?

thanks
Samad

you are an alumni of CMI aren't you ?
 
  • #48
samad.kidwai said:
Why should they have a diferent pattern every year?? Its annoying enuff understanding the JEE and AIEEE patterns let alone having to work differnetly for every college ..

Haha, notice the quotes I put around pattern. I meant, they should have different kinds of questions. For my entrance test, we had a few MCQ's and few subjective problems. That's more than enough "types of questions". It's annoying indeed to have so many types or problems/marking schemes (match the following? )

could you please have a look at the sample paper and let me knw if the exam you gave had that hard Q's ?

I did, after you last post. It's been 4 years since I gave that exam, but I think the questions given there are comparable to what we got. The thing is(was), even though they might seem hard, one has(I had) more time in this exam to solve the questions from first principles, contrary to JEE or AIEEE where you have to get to the right answer very quickly, the method being irrelevant.
 
  • #49
LOL at match the following :p

thanks a lot for the proompt reply, let's hope i get some old papers from somewhere ...
 
  • #50
what do you think about IGNOU ?
 
  • #51
What is the min percentage in 12th class to get into a good college ,
I am in 12th right now and preparing for JEE in a coaching institute for the last 2 years
 
  • #52
I think I've found the correct place and you people will surely help me.
From mumbai, I gave 12th this year and I got just 72%, I didn't pay attention to boards, prepared for iit jee(advanced) and getting around 30% in it. I solve IIT level problems easily , got low marks because I didn't study chemistry. So is my 1year wasted and taking a drop is the only option left?
Even I'm interested in pure sciences and want to become physicist.
 
  • #53
i have secured 92.75 from isc board(english included)..what are my chances of landing up in a good college.?rather i must ask what good colleged should i apply for.?
# i have an eca quota(debates) with quite a good nb of certificates.?
 
  • #54
ManishR said:
what do you think about IGNOU ?

I think the BSc program of IGNOU is good. I have enrolled for it. But I do not know anyone personally who has done the course and then went on to "achieve great things" in physics after that. So, it's a gamble but it is a risk I am willing to take.
 

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 38 ·
2
Replies
38
Views
6K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
3K