Integral proof and then use the proof to solve a 2nd integral

10 replies · 2K views · last reply
Mustard
Messages
21
Reaction score
1
Member warned that some effort must be shown.
Homework Statement
I'm not sure how to go about it tbh :/
Relevant Equations
On the pic
Printed homework problem 16: prove that the integral from 0 to b of f(x)/(f(x)+f(b-x)) dx equals b/2, then use it to evaluate the integral from 0 to 3 of sqrt(x)/(sqrt(x)+sqrt(3-x)) dx, which is 1.
 
PeroK said:
Do you have any ideas yourself?
Well in the the bottom half I would assume you would have to use u-subsitution but I don't believe the question is asking me to solve the bottom until I prove the top is = b/2?
 
Mustard said:
Well in the the bottom half I would assume you would have to use u-subsitution but I don't believe the question is asking me to solve the bottom until I prove the top is = b/2?
Have you tried the obvious substitution?
 
PeroK said:
Have you tried the obvious substitution?
Do you mean substituting b for x?
 
  • Skeptical
Likes   Reactions: PeroK
Mustard said:
Do you mean substituting b for x?
I thought the substitution ##u = b - x## was the first thing you should consider. Especially if you are stuck.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
PeroK said:
I thought the substitution ##u = b - x## was the first thing you should consider. Especially if you are stuck.
Oh , I'm stuck again. Am I doing it right si far ? :/ I'm sorry it's just confusing to me.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation on lined paper: the integral from 0 to b of f(x)/(f(x) - f(b-x)) dx, then substitution x = v - b, v = b - x, giving the integral from b to 0 of f(v-b)/(f(v-b) - f(v)) times (-dv), with du/dx = -1 and -dv = dx.
    16077677046055021006553674498180.jpg
    42 KB · Views: 197
Mustard said:
Oh , I'm stuck again. Am I doing it right si far ? :/ I'm sorry it's just confusing to me.
Yes. You need to tidy that up and, strictly speaking, you are missing an equals sign.
 
Mustard said:
Oh , I'm stuck again. Am I doing it right si far ? :/ I'm sorry it's just confusing to me.
You have a few issues to correct.
Handwritten calculus working on lined paper: the substitution x = u - b at top right, the integral from 0 to b of f(x) over f(x) - f(b-x) dx, and below it the rewritten integral from b to 0 of f(u-b) over f(u-b) - f(u) times (-du), with 'Let u = b - x' and du/dx = -1.

If ##u=b-x##, then ##x=b-u## not ##u-b##.

The denominator is a sum, ##f(x)+f(b-x)##, not a difference.

The integration limits for ##u## are different than for ##x##.

After making these corrections, there will be more work to do to complete your task.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
After you do the necessary corrections outlined in post #9 , you ll have the integral $$\int_b^0-\frac{f(b-u)}{f(b-u)+f(u)}du$$, which is the same as $$\int_0^b \frac{f(b-u)}{f(b-u)+f(u)}du$$. Now you ll have to do a little algebraic trick (adding and subtracting from the numerator the same quantity f(u) )and then by algebraic simplifications you ll get a significant result, namely that the initial integral (the integral involving x, let's call it I) is such that $$I=b-I$$. And this is pretty much the end of it, solving the last equation for I.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: SammyS
Looks to me an exercise in My First Math Book, Chapter 1, Symbols and Functions.

Ex 15: If φ##(f,b) =## ψ##(b)## what is φ##(f, 3)##?

if you can calculate ψ(3) what can you say about φ##(f,3) ## ?