Unclear step in "Change of variable in a multiple integral" proof

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
Unconscious
Messages
77
Reaction score
12
I'm studying the proof of this theorem (Zorich, Mathematical Analysis II, 1st ed., pag.136):

Printed statement of Theorem 1 (11.10): for a diffeomorphism phi from D_t to D_x between bounded open sets, the integral of f over D_x equals the integral of f(phi(t))|det phi'(t)| over D_t.


which as the main idea uses the fact that a diffeomorphism between two open sets can always be locally decomposed in a composition of elementary ones.
As a remark, an elementary diffeomorphism ##\varphi## is a diffeomorphism under which only a single variable is modified (in the following example, the last one):

##\left\{\begin{matrix}
x^1=\varphi^1(t^1,...,t^n)=t^1\\
x^2=\varphi^2(t^1,...,t^n)=t^2\\
...\\
x^{n-1}=\varphi^{n-1}(t^1,...,t^n)=t^{n-1}\\
x^{n}=\varphi^{n}(t^1,...,t^n)
\end{matrix}\right.##

The proposed proof (pag.142) starts in this way:

Printed page of a proof from a calculus text: a compact set K_t covered by finitely many neighborhoods, with delta set to the minimum of the delta(t_i) values, and a sentence about sets of small diameter meeting K_t.


I can't understand the last sentence, because as an intuitively counterexample I'm imagining out this situation:

Diagram of a region D_t with a smaller square K_t inside it, covered by overlapping circles centred on dots, with a red radius labelled delta and a small pink ellipse near the right edge of K_t.


where the pink set is a set with a diameter less than ##\delta##, that intersect ##K_t##, but that is not contained in any neighborhoods of the finite family covering ##K_t##.
Am I missing something?
 
I think [itex]U(t_1), \dots, U(t_k)[/itex] is meant. The truth of that is a consequence of the triangle rule, and the consequence is that any sufficiently small neighbourhood is contained within a neighbourhood where [itex]\varphi[/itex] decomposes as claimed. (Compare the proof of the Heine-Cantor Theorem.)
 
I post again in this thread, because I have another question on the same argument.
I'm studying this generalization (pag.145) of the previous theorem:

Text of Theorem 2 with equations 11.17 and 11.18: a change of variables formula for Lebesgue-measurable Jordan sets D_t and D_x with mapping phi, relating integrals of f over D_x to integrals of f composed with phi times |det phi'| over D_t, with subsets S_t and S_x of measure zero.


whose proof begins in this way:

Page of a mathematics textbook showing Theorem 2 on change of variables in multiple integrals, with equations 11.17 and 11.18, followed by a proof paragraph about open and closed sets and covering by intervals.


where my doubt is on the highlighted relation.
I think that it would be ##x\in\partial D_x \cup S_x## instead ##x\in\partial D_x \setminus S_x##, no?
If I'm wrong, then I can't understand the successive relation ##\overline{V}_x\subset D_x\setminus S_x##, because I can't see why a point of ##\partial V_x## could not be inside ##S_x##.
 
Last edited: