Interesting math problem that I saw online

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Charles Link
  • Start date
  • Featured
92 replies · 12K views · last reply
@anuttarasammyak It really might be worth taking a closer look at it to see why it worked out so well. One thing that came as a little bit of a surprise was when computing the cosine factors that come up for the angles of @bob012345 's post 72, they turned out to contain 53 x root 3,37 x root 3, and 17 x root 3. Meanwhile the 9867 that also comes up in the calculation is 9867=23 x 13 x 11 x 3. The arithmetic (referring to that of post 72) was rather amazing that finally resulted in the answer ## x=1/23 ##.

I had no idea when I made up this problem (post 66) a couple days ago that it would give such an interesting result. :)
 
I now found another way to solve the case presented in post 66 that even shows why the ## x=1/23 ## that we get for the solution is rational.
If we let the angle between the sides of length 2 and 4 be ## \theta ##, this angle will be the same for both the 3,2,4,5 case and the x,2,4,5 case because the radius of the circle is the same for both cases. The law of cosines can be used to find ## \cos{\theta} ## for the 3,2,4,5 case as we have done previously:
(## 2^2+4^2-2(2)(4) \cos{\theta}=3^2+5^2-2(3)(5) \cos(180-\theta) ## ##=3^2+5^2+2(3)(5) \cos{\theta} ## ).
The result is ## \cos{\theta}=-7/23 ##.

The cosine of the angle between the 3 and 5 and also between the x and 5 is ## +7/23 ##, because the complimentary angles add to 180 degrees.

We can apply the law of cosines to the ## x ## and ## 5 ## and obtain ## 2^2+4^2-2(2)(4)(-7/23)=x^2+5^2-2(5)(x)(7/23) ##. When we solve this quadratic equation using the quadratic formula, we get ## x=3 ## and ## x=1/23 ##.

The ## x=3 ## solution was going to be there, because the angle between the (small ) ## x ## and the 5 is the same as the angle between the 3 and the 5 because they are opposite the 2 and 4 in both cases. Since the ## x=3 ## is rational, the ## x=1/23 ## solution had to be rational.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: bob012345 and anuttarasammyak