Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the suitability of the 8th edition of Kittel's introductory solid state physics book for a course, with participants sharing their experiences and recommendations regarding different editions and alternative texts.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Conceptual clarification
- Technical explanation
Main Points Raised
- One participant expresses concern about the negative feedback regarding the 8th edition of Kittel and seeks alternatives.
- Another participant suggests that Ashcroft and Mermin is more basic and could serve as a supplement to Kittel's book.
- Some participants indicate a preference for older editions of Kittel, specifically mentioning the 3rd edition as favorable.
- There is a mention that Ashcroft and Mermin might be perceived as more advanced than Kittel, despite earlier claims of it being more basic.
- One participant notes that for topics like bandgaps and semiconductors, a book focused on Electronics and Semiconductors may provide better conceptual understanding, while Kittel contains the necessary mathematics.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not reach a consensus on the best edition of Kittel or whether Ashcroft and Mermin is more basic or advanced. Multiple competing views regarding the suitability of different texts remain present.
Contextual Notes
Participants reference personal experiences with various editions of Kittel and Ashcroft and Mermin, but there is no agreement on which is definitively better for introductory solid state physics.
Who May Find This Useful
Students preparing for courses in solid state physics, educators seeking textbook recommendations, and individuals interested in the comparative merits of different physics texts.