The discussion revolves around the specifications related to fluid mixing and seepage limits in heat exchangers, particularly focusing on the importance of these parameters in various applications. Participants explore whether such specifications exist in manufacturer literature or standards and their relevance to operational integrity.
There appears to be a general agreement among participants that leakage through tubesheets is not acceptable in practical applications, particularly in critical systems like nuclear steam generators. However, the existence of formal classifications for leakage in heat exchangers remains uncertain, indicating some disagreement or lack of consensus on this point.
Participants reference specific applications and standards, but there is no consensus on the existence of formal specifications for leakage in heat exchangers beyond anecdotal evidence. The discussion also highlights the potential variability in definitions and standards across different types of heat exchangers.
Engineers and professionals involved in the design, manufacturing, and maintenance of heat exchangers, particularly in industries where leakage could have significant operational implications, may find this discussion relevant.
Muti said:. Doug statement can be taken as there is no leakage through tubesheet practically.
To the limits of Minimum Detectable Activity.Muti said:[ ... ] Doug statement can be taken as there is no leakage through tubesheet practically.