Is it impossible to separate a distance of 1light hour in space?

  • #1
104
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

Is it impossible to separate a distance of "1light hour" in space?

i was having a debate with a guy on a site and he argues it is impossible to separate such a distance in space.
Suppose two observers A & B they are relatively at rest, A wish to do an experiment so A & B moves apart by sending laser signals, after a huge amount of time, they slows down their speed to get accurate measuremet, A continuously sends a laser beam to B and B does the same. A notices that a laser beam sent to B took exactly 2 hours to return, which means A is now exactly 1 light hour distant apart. B also does this, so B also concludes that he is exactly 1 light hour away from A. They does this until finally they became relatively at rest to eachother
Or do they disagree?
When A Calculates exact 1 light hour distance, won't that be 1lhr for B??
His arguement was when one of the observers calculate his distance, the other won't get the same measurement because of different frames
Is his argument correct?
Is there really no way to separate a distance in space?
Even i tried saying there is a 1lhr long nebula between these two observers, still he won't agree
 
Last edited:

Answers and Replies

  • #2
phinds
Science Advisor
Insights Author
Gold Member
2019 Award
16,080
6,051
I see nothing wrong with your argument. You have specified a valid way to separate two observers by one light hour.
 
  • #3
34,234
10,278
It is important to be at rest relative to each other (you can check this via Doppler shifts, for example). If you are, you can measure the distance easily, and both will agree on the value. If you are moving slowly, the measurements will look a bit different, but you can still approach the final state of zero relative velocity.
 
  • #4
418
29
There has been a misunderstanding of the conditions of the experiment, the original question was:

"Consider an object 'O' is travelling towards me at 90% speed of light which is placed at 1hr c away ....".

The distance in the object's frame depends on when it is measured which wasn't specified.
 
  • #5
phinds
Science Advisor
Insights Author
Gold Member
2019 Award
16,080
6,051
There has been a misunderstanding of the conditions of the experiment, the original question was:

"Consider an object 'O' is travelling towards me at 90% speed of light which is placed at 1hr c away ....".

The distance in the object's frame depends on when it is measured which wasn't specified.
You seem to be addressing something from some other thread. What you quoted isn't here.
 
  • #6
418
29
You seem to be addressing something from some other thread. What you quoted isn't here.
The original post starts "i was having a debate with a guy on a site ...". I was that guy, the quote is from the other site (a Facebook group). The poster linked this thread in the original thread.
 
  • #7
34,234
10,278
Let's continue the discussion in this thread, two threads for the same topic are bad.
 

Related Threads on Is it impossible to separate a distance of 1light hour in space?

  • Last Post
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
52
Views
10K
  • Last Post
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
22
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
964
Replies
6
Views
12K
Replies
4
Views
962
Replies
19
Views
2K
Top