Is Starting Smoking Worth the Potential Health Risks?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Surrealist
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary
Anxiety and depression are significantly impacting the individual's ability to focus on research and daily activities, leading to thoughts about smoking as a potential stress reliever. However, there is a strong consensus that smoking would exacerbate health issues and addiction, ultimately increasing stress rather than alleviating it. Many participants recommend seeking professional help, emphasizing that therapy can be beneficial despite past negative experiences. Alternatives like exercise and reducing caffeine intake are suggested to manage anxiety. Overall, the discussion highlights the importance of finding healthier coping mechanisms instead of resorting to smoking or substance use.
  • #61
I'd be pleased if Surrealist didn't smoke. At the same time I recognize that it is his decision to make, and not our responsibility to talk him into or out of any decision he is considering. I hope he makes the best decision for himself.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #62
Agreed. It is probably one of the most personal decisions that one can make. The reason that I mentioned the potentially terminal emphysema was to impress upon him just how dangerous it can be to get started.
W's first husband has had it for years. He lives with her daughter, is on oxygen full-time, was just diagnosed with a tumor on his lung last week, and is still smoking.
On the other hand, her second husband died of lung cancer and never smoked in his life until after he got it. He did, however, have the misfortune of doing construction work in buildings with asbestos insulation. My father died of cancer as well, and neither smoked nor drank. Unfortunately, he got this prostate infection...
 
  • #63
My motivation was a bit like Pythagorean's. When a guy that I liked mentioned that he had asthma, I felt like an @$$ for smoking. I had "wanted" (read: had lots of good reasons) to quit before that and had quit a few times for short periods, but that's what did it. I don't like him anymore, but I wouldn't start smoking again.

I think it is your decision, so I can only say that I wish you guys would reconsider. Do you remember what it feels like to be smoke-free? Maybe you would enjoy it more. If you tried it and didn't like it as much, you could always go back to smoking again. Are you worried that you might miss it? You can always go back.
 
  • #64
Danger said:
Sometimes I just got to sit back and shake my head... :biggrin:

:wink:

I understand why you would say that. However i just want to make sure the OP gets to know "all opinions out there". Not everybody is against smoking. Some of us, like me, really reaaaallllyyy like it.

Just a few insights for the OP when he/she is making the actual decision :

1) Smoke all you want, but keep doing sports as well. I regularly play tennis and squash to keep my physical condition onto a "certain acceptable level". I assure you that i would outplay many non smoking "look at me i am so healthy" anti tabacco people.

2) Smoke in style, not like some marginal retard. The way you position the cigarette with respect to your hand is ESSENTIAL. If you are really good, you can even develop your own style of smoking, but just make sure you look authentic.

3) Only smoke to enjoy it. Cigarettes are a product of luxury ! Don't forget that.

4) Never smoke in the presence of young children and pregnant women.

5) Always offer a fellow smoker a cigarette when asked to, unless you cannot stand the guy/girl.

6) You will always be able to socialize with the smoking community and you will be surprised of how many intelligent/creative people make up this group. As a matter of fact, most really creative people have a natural tendency for addiction. Them moral knights of the physical health are just plain old boring people that do not know how to pass their time (unless they do some boring sport which kills any kind of creative stimulus, like jogging).

7) Make sure your partner smokes as well or has an open mind about it. Nobody likes a closed minded racist !

8) Don't worry too much about reducing life expectancy, being dead is not so bad ! I mean, don't we all like to sleep long hours ? YES we do, except those boring sports people that like to get up at 0600 am to do some boring uncreative "jogging".

9) ENJOY ENJOY ENJOY SMOKING !

http://img524.imageshack.us/img524/7145/hahahawf0.th.jpg
greets
marlon
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #65
Marlon, your approach to life never ceases to astound and impress me.
As far as the athletics thing goes, I have to agree with you. Back when I was playing ball, our rag-tag team was the joke of the league. We were the scrawniest, least athletic, heaviest drinking and most smoking bunch of losers in the league... and we consistently beat the living **** out of the 'super-jocks'. :biggrin:
 
  • #66
Marlon should be French if he's not already. The two sports the have are cycling and extreme smoking.
 
  • #67
And yet the biggest dilemma I've had all day has been whether or not I should eat a cookies n creme drumstick. It has 350 calories. I'm not overweight at all. Why do I have this dilemma then? I burned 400 calories doing cardio today. Knowing how much it takes to burn 350 calories makes me think twice about eating this drumstick... BUT IT'S SO GOOD! OMG!
 
  • #68
Kurdt said:
Marlon should be French if he's not already.

:approve:
I would love to be French, living in the south. They got a great president now. But i am Belgian, which is NOT the same !

The two sports the have are cycling and extreme smoking.
and soccer, having sex etc etc

marlon
 
  • #69
marlon said:
8) Don't worry too much about reducing life expectancy, being dead is not so bad ! I mean, don't we all like to sleep long hours ?

I respect a person's right to choose to smoke, but this is awfully deceptive. I'll disregard the absurd comparison between sleep and death, but there are other things to consider. For one thing, this isn't just about when you die, it's also about pain. Smoking often adds to the slew of health problems you develop with age -- one should consider the increased likelihood of aging into a breath-starved, hoarse-voiced invalid. Even when you're young, smoking will usually decrease your overall health. That marlon can beat a non-smoker at tennis is hardly evidence against that.

Note that, regardless of the demographics of smokers, smoking will not make someone more creative. That Lou Reed lit up from time to time should have no bearing on your own decisions about smoking. Also keep in mind that, despite marlon's penchant for stereotype, you won't find that morals are a big factor in most people's decision to smoke. In fact, many people just find it disgusting and may be inclined to spend less time with you if you're constantly lighting up. You'll find that many smokers are insecure about this fact and will try to rationalize it by telling themselves that they're cooler, more open-minded, or less judgemental.

All that said, I do think people should have the right to smoke if they want. As long as they understand the risks and sacrifices, then they should do what makes them happy. I suggest talking to some older smokers who have been through the many trials and tribulations of smoking. They might have some more valuable insights.
 
Last edited:
  • #70
it is much easier to start than to stop, so i suggest, no, don't start. It took me 35 years to stop after first starting. And tonight at my friend's house, his cigar still smelled tempting to me, 15 years after quitting.
 
  • #71
Danger said:
Thank you for that, Circles. You nailed it. I don't need sympathy, I don't want it, and I certainly don't deserve it. I was merely pointing out the sort of traps that are out there when one starts messing about with nasty substances.
Jason, despite whatever admiration you hold for your relatives, you obviously have no concept of what addiction is. I can easily quit both drinking and smoking cold turkey. The point is, I don't want to. That is the serious side of being addicted; I enjoy both so much that I'm willing to face the physical and financial hardships attendant thereto.
My habits have no detrimental effect upon my work or home life, and I hope none toward my admittedly meager contributions to the Physics and Engineering forums. Should they start to do so, I'll change.

I know you don't want to. That's a reason for being harsh.

I'm sorry, but that's just the way it is.

Note: I never thought you were looking for sympathy.
 
  • #72
Well I find it quite ironic that you want to strat smoking to get rid of stress, but are already stressed out about it!

SpaceTiger said:
If you have to ask, then Darwin would say yes.
:smile:


marlon said:
:wink:

I understand why you would say that. However i just want to make sure the OP gets to know "all opinions out there". Not everybody is against smoking. Some of us, like me, really reaaaallllyyy like it.
I think you L0VE it, 'like' couldn't be a good word here to express your feelings towards smoking!:smile:
Good advice, BTW!

Regards
 
Last edited:
  • #73
Kurdt said:
Marlon should be French if he's not already. The two sports the have are cycling and extreme smoking.

:smile:

Extra text
 
  • #74
I am a very mellow person by nature, but when I do get upset or anxious a good smoke does help a lot.
I don’t know if it is the cig or just having something to take my mind off things but it does help.

As for the health risks, yah I know it is bad for me but what the hell.
I have been smoking for about 20 years and I seem to be still able to do everything I always did.
But remember different people react differently, however my lungs are unusually large (That is just a thing in my family though)
 
  • #75
SpaceTiger said:
I respect a person's right to choose to smoke, but this is awfully deceptive.
NOT your decision to make. Remember that you are not the moral judge of PF.

I suggest talking to some older smokers who have been through the many trials and tribulations of smoking. They might have some more valuable insights.
I think that is quite stupid advice. The age of the smoker should not be the primary factor here but the length of period he/she has been smoking. I would value the advice more of a guy in his 40ties who has been smoking for 25 years instead of some 60year old that just started to smoke 10 years ago.


marlon
 
  • #76
Yah I got this bad habit after an exam of having a couple cigerattes and drinks, and I don't smoke!:smile:
 
  • #77
SpaceTiger said:
Note that, regardless of the demographics of smokers, smoking will not make someone more creative.
Did anyone ever say that ?
Also keep in mind that, despite marlon's penchant for stereotype,
Awww that's so sad man. Really, if you ain't got nothing to say, just don't speak. Get a smoke and relax !

You'll find that many smokers are insecure about this fact and will try to rationalize it by telling themselves that they're cooler, more open-minded, or less judgemental.
I AM VERY JUDGEMENTAL ! What you say here is rubbish. Besides, how on Earth do you know this ? If you have never been a smoker you have absolutely no idea what you are talking about. I AM a smoker and I HAVE been a non-smoker. So, i know both sides. Now, my dear moral knight, do YOU ?


marlon
 
  • #78
marlon said:
I would value the advice more of a guy in his 40ties who has been smoking for 25 years instead of some 60year old that just started to smoke 10 years ago.

marlon

LOL. Yeah how many people do you know who started smoking at age 50? :smile:
 
  • #79
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #80
marlon said:
NOT your decision to make. Remember that you are not the moral judge of PF.

This is not a moral issue and there are no moral judgements being made. I said that your statements about the consequences of smoking were deceptive. That means that I'm challenging your facts, not your ethics.


I think that is quite stupid advice. The age of the smoker should not be the primary factor here but the length of period he/she has been smoking. I would value the advice more of a guy in his 40ties who has been smoking for 25 years instead of some 60year old that just started to smoke 10 years ago.

The health problems caused by smoking are much more likely to develop in old age, but you're right that it wouldn't make sense to ask a 60-year-old who just started smoking. I figured it was obvious enough in what i wrote that the person they ask should be a veteran smoker, not just an old person, but if that's all you've got to work with...
 
  • #81
marlon said:
Awww that's so sad man. Really, if you ain't got nothing to say, just don't speak. Get a smoke and relax !I AM VERY JUDGEMENTAL ! What you say here is rubbish. Besides, how on Earth do you know this ? If you have never been a smoker you have absolutely no idea what you are talking about.

You don't have to jump off a cliff to know that it's a bad idea. If you think that you do, however, I think Darwin would say that you should.

By the way, for someone who claims to be so chill, you're awfully worked up. I have no moral problem with smoking, but is it possible that you do?
 
  • #82
Egads! I've just seen this thread and CANNOT believe people are recommending ANYONE should START smoking! It's simple...don't start. If you never start, you never have to deal with trying to quit or all the other horrid health effects of smoking. It's just plain STUPID to ever start smoking. Once someone has made that mistake, it's incredibly hard to stop...just look at all the rationalizing the smokers are making to excuse their habit here. If you want to do something terribly stupid and start yourself on a bad habit that's hard to stop and has about a 50/50 odds of killing you with a disease that will include a lot of suffering for you and your loved ones, you certainly are free to do so, but I can't believe anyone would in good conscience encourage such a thing, or that this thread has gone on so long allowing such encouragement. I'm not going to let a thread continue that encourages self-destructive behavior.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 66 ·
3
Replies
66
Views
7K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 41 ·
2
Replies
41
Views
8K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
2K