Is There a Mistake in My Proof for the Identity of Pauli Spin Matrices?

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
4 replies · 5K views
InGaAsP
Messages
4
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



prove the idendity [tex]\sigma \times \sigma =i \sigma[/tex] where [tex]\sigma[/tex] is Pauli Spin matrices

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



This is how I did..and I am getting
2[tex]i \sigma[/tex] instead of [tex]i\sigma[/tex].

http://i146.photobucket.com/albums/r273/soorajr/paulimatrix.jpg

This question was asked twice for the university exam, and during both times, they asked us to prove [tex]\sigma \times \sigma =i \sigma[/tex].
Did i make any mistake? or the examiner was wrong?
Thanks in advance.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
You wrote (for instance) [itex]\sigma_y\sigma_z-\sigma_z\sigma_y=i\sigma_x[/itex]
but then later when you get the same expression for the x-component you enter
[itex]i\sigma_x+i\sigma_x[/itex], which is where your factor 2 comes from.
Check the middle line in your calculation of the determinant again
 
Galileo said:
You wrote (for instance) [itex]\sigma_y\sigma_z-\sigma_z\sigma_y=i\sigma_x[/itex]
but then later when you get the same expression for the x-component you enter
[itex]i\sigma_x+i\sigma_x[/itex], which is where your factor 2 comes from.
Check the middle line in your calculation of the determinant again

Thanks Galileo for ur reply

the results i used were[tex]\sigma_x\sigma_y=-\sigma_y\sigma_x=i\sigma_z[/tex]
i changed x,y,z cyclicly, and hence reached at 2[tex]i \sigma[/tex]
do u think I am supposed to get only i[tex]\sigma[/tex] instead of 2i[tex]\sigma[/tex]
thanks in advance
 
Last edited:
InGaAsP said:

Homework Statement



prove the idendity [tex]\sigma \times \sigma =i \sigma[/tex] where [tex]\sigma[/tex] is Pauli Spin matrices

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



This is how I did..and I am getting
2[tex]i \sigma[/tex] instead of [tex]i\sigma[/tex].

http://i146.photobucket.com/albums/r273/soorajr/paulimatrix.jpg

This question was asked twice for the university exam, and during both times, they asked us to prove [tex]\sigma \times \sigma =i \sigma[/tex].
Did i make any mistake? or the examiner was wrong?
Thanks in advance.

Yes, there is a mistake in the question. There really should be a factor fo 2 there.
 
Indeed, your first lines should be [itex]\sigma_y\sigma_z-\sigma_z\sigma_y=2i\sigma_x[/itex] etc.