Kinematics, Displacement from Velocity-Time

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves kinematics, specifically focusing on the displacement of a vehicle from its velocity-time characteristics during deceleration. The scenario describes a driver who must stop his vehicle after noticing an obstacle, with given initial velocity, stopping time, and distance from the obstacle.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the use of different equations for calculating distance during deceleration, questioning the appropriateness of using trapezoidal versus triangular area interpretations in a velocity-time context.
  • Some participants explore the implications of sign conventions for velocity and acceleration, particularly in relation to directionality and deceleration.
  • Questions arise about the validity of using various kinematic equations under constant acceleration conditions.

Discussion Status

The discussion is ongoing, with participants providing insights and clarifications on the calculations and concepts involved. There is an exchange of ideas regarding the interpretation of velocity signs and the application of kinematic equations, indicating a productive exploration of the topic.

Contextual Notes

Participants are navigating the complexities of sign conventions in vector quantities and the implications of using different equations for motion under constant acceleration. There is also a focus on visualizing the problem in terms of geometric interpretations of distance on a graph.

cidilon
Messages
11
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Andrew is driving his van to deliver groceries in Elmvale. As he travels along Hwy 92, a fox stops on the road. Andrew is traveling at 75 km/h [North] and is 42 m away from the fox when he applies his brakes. It takes him 3.4 s to stop.

a) How far did Andrew travel before stopping?

v1 = -75 km/h [North] or -20.8 m/s [North] (It has to be negative because he is decelerating, right?)
v2 = 0
t = 3.4 s


Homework Equations



From looking at some examples, i believe i am supposed to use
d = .5(v2-v1)t + v1*t
or if i find acceleration first
d = v1*t + .5*a*t*t


The Attempt at a Solution



d = .5(v2-v1)t + v1*t
d = .5*(0+20.8)*3.4 - 20.8*3.4
d = -35.36 m [North] or -35 m [North]

As final velocity is known, can i use d = v2*t - .5(v2-v1)t or d = .5(v2+v1)t instead and does it matter?

What i am confused about is that d = .5(v2+v1)t is the area of a trapezoid, where as the slope as i imagine it for this word problem, makes a triangle. How is the area of a trapezoid working for a triangle? Does the slope NOT make a triangle? Should i not visualize this problem?

I really hope that i made myself clear, as it has been bugging me quite a lot!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
All your calculations seem correct and so does your answer :)

cidilon said:
v1 = -75 km/h [North] or -20.8 m/s [North] (It has to be negative because he is decelerating, right?)

This is not correct. The sign of acceleration does NOT affect the velocity. The sign of the velocity is only determined by its direction (since it's a vector). If you're going to give the velocity a sign, you'll have to determine which direction is positive (for example, west could be + and east, -) but in this case since there aren't different directions of velocities, that's pointless.

cidilon said:
As final velocity is known, can i use d = v2*t - .5(v2-v1)t or d = .5(v2+v1)t instead and does it matter? !
If both equations are correct, and since acceleration is constant (some equations require constant acceleration), you should be able to use both to determine the distance.

cidilon said:
What i am confused about is that d = .5(v2+v1)t is the area of a trapezoid, where as the slope as i imagine it for this word problem, makes a triangle. How is the area of a trapezoid working for a triangle? Does the slope NOT make a triangle? Should i not visualize this problem?
Distance will not be a slope, it will be an area on a graph just like work would be. It'll be velocity*time on a graph.
Hope this helps!
 
amy andrews said:
All your calculations seem correct and so does your answer :)

This is not correct. The sign of acceleration does NOT affect the velocity. The sign of the velocity is only determined by its direction (since it's a vector). If you're going to give the velocity a sign, you'll have to determine which direction is positive (for example, west could be + and east, -) but in this case since there aren't different directions of velocities, that's pointless.

I was actually just thinking about this, it looked somewhat odd to me!
I got the idea in an example that i saw earlier. It was a similar problem but acceleration was found first. It went something like this "Kareem was driving his truck at 94 km/h [west]. He starts to apply brakes when he notice the stop sign ahead. It takes him 28 s to come to a complete stop"

For the answer on the other hand they used -94km/h [west] /28s = -0.93m/s2 [west] or 0.93m/s2 [east]. Why was the velocity made negative in this case? I understand that the acceleration needs to be negative because the object is decelerating. Is it okay to make it negative in case of acceleration?

Explain this to me and i think i will be good to go :) hehe
 
Yep, the acceleration will be negative since the velocity is going down (it's decelerating).
Glad to help ;)
 
Wonderful, thanks a lot! :)
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
40
Views
3K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
4K
Replies
5
Views
4K